Mudda panellists discuss change in BJP attitude towards the community, wonder if it is not an expedient response to anger among them in wake of atrocities and a measure to preserve its vote bank ahead of elections
Will spending two nights in Dalit villages restore the faith of the community in the BJP? APN’s iconic debate show, Mudda, debated the prime minister’s call to party MPs to do just so four days after the Bharat Bandh by community members on the BJP’s 38th foundation day. Participants included BJP spokesperson Ashwini Upadhyay, Congress spokeswoman Suchi Biswas, SP leader Jagdev Singh, RPI leader Mahavir Sonwane, thinker on Dalit issues Avdhesh Verma and journalist Govind Pant Raju. The discussion was conducted by Anant Tyagi.
“It is a routine exercise. We have always working for the good of the poor; we never discriminated against any demographic. Our policies and schemes have been inclusive; some examples are Ayushman Bharat, Jan Dhan Yojana, etc. We just haven’t been vocal about it,” said Upadhyay. Antyodaya is our goal, he added.
Biswas, however, felt that the prime minister’s awakening was indeed sudden. “Is it shame or damage control? What has the BJP indeed done for the Dalits except distributing soap and shampoo among them when any of their leaders came visiting? The Jan Dhan Yojana has not added money to Dalits’accounts, loan waivers were announced but the actual waivers were a cruel joke on the UP farmers. Besides, it is the Congress which passed the untouchability law in parliament,” said she.
Raju disagreed that any progress had happened due to laws or political parties, what happened was due to social change and spread of literacy, he said. “No politician has ever worked honestly for Dalits. Even Mayawati of the BSP copped out of the Navodaya higher education scheme after winning her last election on that very promise,” he said.
Crimes against Dalits have risen since 2014, said Verma. Important bills are pending in parliament, he added. “If Dalit MPs of the ruling party allege exploitation, nothing more is required to prove that the BJP is anti-Dalit,” he said.
It was Mulayam Singh who made Kansiram MP for the first time from Etawah. It is the SP which has worked for the Dalits and is their only friend, said Singh.
“Ramdas Athawale has appealed in court on the matter and has spoken to the prime minister. The Congress and others are blaming the BJP wrongly for the mess,” said Sonwane.
Is the BJP more interested in Dalit votes than Dalit welfare, Tyagi again asked.
In reply, Upadhyay informed the audience of the Sabka Saath Sabka Vikas Yatra which will start on April 14 and end on May 5. “We have taken quick action against atrocities,” he added. He then accused SP of going easy on terrorists. He would not let Verma speak.
Verma said, “This is the exact attitude of the BJP towards Dalits. We have been robbed of our voice.” He asked the government for a white paper on the Rohith Vemula case, the Una case, the Koregaon violence and the Saharanpur clashes.
Upadhyay was unable to respond to Verma’s questions.
Raju said the BJP move, if aimed at saving its vote bank, would not yield results. At the same time, he said that those Dalit MPs speaking up against the policy of the government were only announcing their plans to leave the party and join another in the near future.
—Compiled by Sucheta Dasgupta