English हिन्दी
Connect with us

Latest Politics News

Jallikattu: Political rumblings on the Marina?

Published

7 years ago

on

Protestors at Marina Beach, Chennai, demanding that the ban on jallikattu be lifted. Photos: UNI

[vc_row][vc_column][vc_column_text]Making sense of mass protests against the ban on jallikattu

SS Kumar

The jallikattu protests animating Tamil Nadu over the last week are not really about jallikattu: anything but. And it’s not about spontaneity, again.

Of the tens of thousands gathered at the Marina—under the benign and approving eye of the state police—it’s unlikely even one percent is likely to have seen a jallikattu performance. If it was about anything, it was about Tamil pride: read, a palpable sense of Tamil victimhood.

T Ramakrishnan, the son of the noted Tamil writer Ashokamitran, a senior Hindu journalist and a keen political observer, suggested: If J Jayalalithaa were alive, this wouldn’t be happening. How so? The jallikattu ban cropped up in 2015 and 2016, but roused no passions as long as Jaya was around; after that, it was an issue waiting to happen. Whether this says anything about the Tamil psyche and its yearning for a strong imperious leader like her, MGR, or M Karunanidhi or not, there is a perception that Tamilians’ maryaadai (respect, pride) was at stake. This, in essence, is what it’s about.

So, ordinary Tamils chafing at what they perceive are slights … Karnataka defying the Supreme Court and withholding Cauvery water, Kerala’s intransigence over the Mullaperiyar dam, and a feeling that the central government was not sympathetic to the state… waiting for an issue to vent all that pent up feeling.

And happen it did after an extraordinary series of circumstances. The immediate provocation was a report that spread like wildfire that central government offices would stay open in the state on Pongal day with Tamil staff allowed the day off, when the practice was that central government offices were closed for Pongal… as for other regional holidays in other states.

That marked the start: in no time, it spread from the traditional jallikattu areas in central Tamil Nadu—Alanganallur in Madurai district is the epicentre of the jallikattu tradition, a hangover from a feudal sport of the mirasdars/zamindars, much like the gladiatorial contests of ancient Rome. No more, no less… and certainly not intrinsic to Tamil culture, or the state as a whole—jallikattu is unheard of in the Nilgiris district; the northern districts of the state where Chennai lies; or the deep south.

And yet, groups of protesters in every locality, every major traffic junction, every neighbourhood are raising the slogan “jallikattu vendum” (we want jallikattu) as if their birthright was being snatched away.

On the Marina, the crowd chanted, “Tamizhan endru sollu da, thalai nimirnthu nillu da (Say you’re a Tamil, hold your head up high!).” On Friday, January 20, the swelling youth protest against the ban on jallikattu (the sport of bull taming, literally the (salli) coins tied to a bull’s horns (kattu) entered into its fourth day—leaving the government scrambling to find a solution.

How much of a role did social media play in propelling the demonstrations? Many have cited WhatsApp as a key driver—interestingly, as I was writing this, a mail dropped into my box, extolling Tamil as the only surviving classical language (with a link to a Hindu article), and concluding with the ringing declaration that “Tamilian is not identified by caste and community, but a powerful organised civilization.” And the punchline at the end: Tamilan endru sollada. Coincidence? Hardly.

But the anonymous e-mail from windmerumalai@gmail.com made an interesting point—the students seem united by a Tamil identity, an identity transcending caste and community, so ingrained in Tamil society, just below the surface, seething, simmering… and ready to explode into violence. One of the striking things is the sheer numbers of women and children at the protest, and the sight of scores of young Muslim women with head scarves. Yes, community transcended.

Spontaneity? The organisation was far too efficient and streamlined for this to be the case. Food packets—and the well-loved biryani—kept arriving by the truckloads, with teams of volunteers at hand to distribute them; chai served up as a welcome drink; mobile toilets and caravans for women to freshen up. No, it was being orchestrated; but by who?

One clue: Narendra Modi has quickly become the villain of the piece. If Modi and the BJP, scented an opportunity after Jaya’s passing to make inroads, it’s certainly been set back. Many in political circles believe it’s an attempt by Christian and Muslim groups to foster a pan-Tamil identity to keep Hindutva forces from regrouping.

If that is indeed the case, then the strategy has been a smashing success; established parties have been left behind and are now scrambling to catch up, lest they lose their relevance too. The ruling AIADMK, DMK, the Left, the Pattali Makkal Katchi, even fringe pro-Eelam and Dalit outfits, who’ve always exerted an influence all out of proportion to their numbers, must be scratching their heads.

Although the Modi government has approved an ordinance brought about by the Tamil Nadu government in favour of jallikattu but what it has done is to unleash Tamil identity politics again. The last time it happened, during the anti-Hindi riots of 1965, it led to the decimation of the Congress and the rise of the Dravidian parties: a tectonic shift. Will jallikattu do the same?

—the writer is a former associate editor of The Hindu, The Hindu
BusinessLine and Acting Editor of The New Sunday Express

Lead picture: Protestors at Marina Beach, Chennai, demanding that the ban on jallikattu be lifted. Photos: UNI[/vc_column_text][/vc_column][/vc_row]

Related Topics:
Continue Reading

Latest Politics News

Mizoram election result LIVE: ZPM wins 9 assembly seats, all set to unseat MNF; counting underway

In the Mizoram assembly election, the key players are the ruling Mizo National Front (MNF) led by Chief Minister Zoramthanga, Zoram People’s Movement (ZPM) led by Lalduhoma, and the Congress.

Published

15 mins ago

on

December 4, 2023

By

ZPM candidate wins Aizawl South assembly seat 

ZPM candidate  C Lalsawivunga won Aizwal South assembly seat with a margin of 3625 votes.

MNF candidate wins from Thorang assembly seat

MNF candidate R Rohmingliana won from the Thorang assembly seat with a short margin of 62 votes. 

MNF leading in 11 seats

The ruling MNF is leading in 11 assembly seats namely, Hachhek, Dampa, Mamit, Tuirial, Serlui, Tuivawl, Lengteng, East Tuipui, Thorang, West Tuipui, Tuichawng.

ZPM wins from Hrangturzo assembly seat

ZPM candidate Lalmuanpuia Punte won from Hrangtuezo assembly seat with a margin of 1255 votes

BJP candidate wins Palak assembly seat

BJP candidate from K. HRAHMO won from the Palak assembly seat with a margin of 1241 votes. The candidate bagged 6064 votes.

ZPM wins Aizwal West- I assembly seats

ZPM candidate TBC Lalvenchhunga won Aizawl West- I West (15) assembly seat with a margin of 4667 votes

ZPM candidate wins Tawi assembly seat

ZPM candidate Prof Lalnilawma won Tawi assembly seat with a margin of 1552 votes. The candidate gained 6991 total votes. 

Lalfamkima from ZPM wins Kolasib assembly seat

ZPM candidate Lalfamkima won the Kolasib assembly seat with a margin of 1169 votes. Lalfamkima bagged 8657 total votes. 

ZPM wins from South Tuipui

ZPM candidate Jeje Lalpekhlua won from South Tuipui assembly seat with a margin of 135 seats. Lalpekhlua gained 5468 votes.

Not surprised on party’s lead: ZPM chief Lalduhoma

ZPM supremo and Chief Ministerial candidate Lalduhoma expressed that hwe is not surprised at his party’s lead in the Mizoram Assembly election. He added that this is what he expected. 

BJP gains momentum in Chakma stronghold Tuichawng

The BJP has established a lead in the ethnic minority Chakma stronghold of Tuichawng, which is also the only seat it has ever won previously. BJP candidate won from the seat in 2018, making it the saffron party’s first breakthrough in the CHristian majority state.

Deputy Chief Minister Tawnluia loses in Tuichang

According to the Election Commission of India, Mizoram Deputy Chief Minister and MNF candidate from Tuichang seat, Tawnluia lost to ZPM candidate W Chhuanawma by 909 votes.

ZPM wins Aizawl West-11 assembly seat

ZPM candidate Lalnghinglova Hmar won from Aizawl West-II seat with a margin of 4819 seats. 

Everything is peaceful and under control: Aizawl DC Nazuk Kumar

Aizawl DC Nazuk Kumar told news agency PTI that everything is peaceful and that they have enough deployment. She added that they have three-tier security and everything is under control.

ZPM leading in key Aizawl and Lunglei seats

The Zoram People’s Movement is leading in all 9 Aizawl seats, including incumbent Chief Minister Zoramthanga’s Aizawl East-1 seat. Furthermore, the ZPM is also leading in two out of three Lunglei seats. Notably, Lunglei is the second largest town in the state. 

ZPM leads with 28 assembly seats, MNF trails behind with 8 seats

The Zoram People’s Movement is leading with 28 seats, the MNF gained 8 seats, BJP 3 and Congress 1

ZPM claims first victory in Tuichang

The Zoram People’s Movement secures its first victory in Tuichang, defeating incumbent MNF MLA

ZPM crosses halfway mark, MNF trails behind

As per the Election Commission of India, ZPM has crossed the halfway mark and is leading in 27 seats. Meanwhile, MNF gained 9 seats, BJP 3 and Congress 1

Tough battle between ruling MNF and ZPM

The ZPM party leads with 15 assembly seats, ruling MNF gains 12 seats, Congress 9 and BJP 2

ZPM leads with 19 seats, MNF 14, Congress 6

So far, the ruling MNF party in Mizoram gained 14 seats, ZPM leads with 19 seats, Congress 6 and BJP 1

Counting of votes is being held in 13 centres

Additional Chief Electoral Officer H Lianzela told news agency PTI that the counting is being carried out at 13 centres across the state. H Lianzela added that one counting hall has been set up for each of the 40 assembly seats at these 13 centres. 

Counting of votes for Mizoram Assembly election is underway

A visual from a counting centre in Serchhip.

ZPM edge past MNF in early trends

Counting of votes began in Mizoram. As per early trends, The Mizo National Front (MNF) has gained 9 seats, Zoram People’s Movement (ZPM) 22, Congress 6, BJP 1. 

Continue Reading

India News

PM Modi says hat-trick victories guarantee 2024 hat-trick

Narendra Modi claimed that dissatisfaction among youth over paper leak and recruitment scam led to ouster the governments of Chhattisgarh, Rajasthan.

Published

16 hours ago

on

December 3, 2023

By

After the BJP’s sweeping victories in the assembly elections of Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Chhattisgarh, Prime Minister Narendra Modi said the victory is of a self-reliant India, honest, transparency and good governance. Hailing that this hat-trick of victories has given guarantee for a 2024 hat-trick, he said that voters do not believe talk in thin air, false promises and rather support a concrete roadmap for development and good governance.

Referring to the Congress demand for a caste census, PM Modi said that some people tried to divide the country on caste lines during the elections. He added that for him there are only four castes namely women, youth, farmers and poor whose empowerment can strengthen the country. He stated that the people from all castes, regions, communities voted for the party and that every poor person feels that he has won.

ELECTION 2023 COVERAGE: Madhya Pradesh | Rajasthan | Chhattisgarh | Telangana

Addressing party workers at the BJP headquarters, the Prime Minister expressed gratitude to the women, mentioning that women believe only BJP can provide guarantee for their security, safety and dignity. He remarked that women empowerment is an important pillar of BJP’s model of development. He also assured the women that all the promises will be fulfilled. 

Referring to Congress’s defeat, Narendra Modi claimed that dissatisfaction among youth over paper leak and recruitment scam led to the ouster of the governments of Chhattisgarh and Rajasthan. He mentioned that be it in Rajasthan, Chhattisgarh or Telangana, the incumbent party was thrown out of power because it was against the youth and had scams in its tenure. Especially thanking the people of Telangana, he said that the BJP will leave no stone unturned in working for them.

Modi underlined that the BJP government not only makes policies but also ensures that they reach the rightful beneficiaries. He further stated that these victories are a clear warning to those who are not ashamed to stand with the corrupt and try to cover up their deeds.

Slamming the opposition alliance INDIA, the Prime Minister asserted that coming together can yield good photo opportunities and media headlines but cannot win people’s trust. He also requested Congress and its allies to not indulge in politics that empower the anti-national forces.

Continue Reading

India News

Welfarism beats the Congress in Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh and Rajasthan

Shivraj Singh Chouhan launched several schemes for women including cash incentives and even delivered two tranches of Rs 3000 each on Rakhi and Karwa Chauth to married women. 

Published

17 hours ago

on

December 3, 2023

By

By Neeraj Mishra

In one giant swoop, the BJP has cornered entire Western and Central India with its latest victories in Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh and Rajasthan. The party now controls the entire cow belt giving it the right platform for 2024.

While Rajasthan was iffy for the Congress, it was overconfident in Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh, where a combination of weak and divided local leadership and women voters eventually brought it down. It has lost Madhya Pradesh 65-164 and Chhattisgarh 34-56.

ELECTION 2023 COVERAGE: Madhya Pradesh | Rajasthan | Chhattisgarh | Telangana

In many ways, these were elections driven by labarthis (beneficiaries) and the BJP proved itself with better planning, strategy and implementation. In Madhya Pradesh, Shivraj Singh Chouhan launched several schemes for women including cash incentives and even delivered two tranches of Rs 3000 each on Rakhi and Karwa Chauth to married women. 

In Chhattisgarh, where the BJP was in the opposition, it adopted a better strategy by promising Rs 12,000 per annum to married women and later getting them to sign some forms which made the signatories believe they would receive the promised benefit later. BJP workers got more than 30 lakh forms signed and in a state with more women voters than men, it surely means something.

In MP, an overconfident Congress made a mess of ticket distribution. Digvijaya Singh grabbed the largest share and brought in all his 90s cabinet. Eventually, they all lost. It is perhaps time to get rid of Digvijaya and Kamal Nath altogether just like Uma Bharti was ex-communicated from the state by the BJP in 2007 after Shivraj became CM. It paved way for the new. 

The loss in both states will hurt the party not only in the three states but its ramifications will be felt at national level with INDIA and other alliances. 

Continue Reading

Trending

-->

© Copyright 2022 APNLIVE.com