English हिन्दी
Connect with us

India News

Mani Shankar Aiyar’s remarks on Hindutva spark political backlash from BJP

Congress leader Mani Shankar Aiyar’s comments on Hindutva at a Kolkata debate have triggered sharp reactions from the BJP, escalating the Hinduism versus Hindutva debate.

Published

on

manishankar aiyer

Veteran Congress leader Mani Shankar Aiyar has triggered a political controversy after describing Hindutva as “Hinduism in paranoia” during a public debate in Kolkata, prompting a strong rebuttal from leaders of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).

Aiyar made the remarks at a discussion titled “Hinduism needs protection from Hindutva”, organised by the Calcutta Debating Circle at the Calcutta Club on Sunday. Several political leaders, legal experts, historians and journalists participated in the debate.

Aiyar draws distinction between Hinduism and Hindutva

Speaking at the event, Aiyar argued that Hinduism and Hindutva are fundamentally different, describing Hinduism as a spiritual and civilisational faith, while calling Hindutva a political ideology that emerged in the early 20th century.

“Hindutva is Hinduism in paranoia. It asks 80 per cent Hindus to feel threatened by 14 per cent Muslims,” Aiyar said, adding that Hinduism had survived and flourished for thousands of years without the need for what he described as political protection.

He referred to incidents involving attacks by vigilante groups and criticised actions against individuals over religious practices, beef consumption and participation in Christmas celebrations. Aiyar also cited writings of Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, contrasting them with the teachings of Mahatma Gandhi and Swami Vivekananda, whom he described as proponents of non-violence and inclusivity.

According to Aiyar, “There is no way Gandhi’s or Vivekananda’s Hinduism can be protected or promoted by Savarkar’s Hindutva.”

BJP leaders push back strongly

Aiyar’s comments drew an immediate response from BJP leaders present at the debate and later from party spokespersons.

BJP MP Sudhanshu Trivedi questioned the framing of the debate itself, arguing that the term “Hindutva” refers to “Hindu tattva” or the essence of Hindu philosophy. He said that associating Hinduism with the suffix “ism” was misleading and dismissive of India’s indigenous traditions.

“When you cherish Hinduism, it is called Hindutva,” Trivedi said, rejecting the distinction drawn by Aiyar.

BJP spokesperson Shehzad Poonawalla accused Aiyar of repeatedly making remarks that, according to him, insult Sanatan Dharma. He claimed that the comments echoed the Congress party’s broader stance on Hindutva.

Poonawalla also referred to past statements by Congress leaders and said that Hindutva has been defined by the Supreme Court as a “way of life.” He accused the party of attempting to portray Hindutva as violent and divisive.

Political debate intensifies

The exchange has added to the ongoing political debate over the relationship between Hinduism and Hindutva, a subject that has remained contentious in Indian politics. While Aiyar defended his views as ideological and historical critique, BJP leaders framed the remarks as an attack on religious identity.

India News

LPU rape rumour row: Students say video statements were scripted

The Lovely Professional University controversy intensified after three students featured in a university video alleged that they were coached and their statements were used without consent.

Published

on

The controversy at Lovely Professional University (LPU) in Punjab has intensified after three students featured in a university clarification video later alleged that they had been instructed what to say and that their statements were used without their consent.

The controversy followed protests at the university over unverified claims that a female student had been sexually assaulted and later died by suicide. Police have not confirmed that such a crime took place.

Students challenge university’s clarification video

LPU Registrar Dr Monika Gulati had released a video addressing the unrest and featured three students who live in Room 504 of Girls’ Hostel 3, which had been mentioned in claims circulating among students.

In the university’s video, the three students denied that any such incident had taken place in their room and asked students and police not to disturb them.

The registrar subsequently said the unrest was linked to false and fabricated rumours and described the developments as a conspiracy to defame the university.

However, a separate video later emerged in which the same students said they had been instructed by the LPU administration about what to say.

One of the students alleged that they were told to record the statements and that part of the video was edited before being posted on Instagram. The student also said their consent had not been taken.

Another student said they had no involvement in the alleged incident and asked people to leave them alone.

What triggered the LPU protests

The protests began after claims spread among students that a female student had allegedly been sexually assaulted on campus and had subsequently died by suicide.

One protesting student alleged that the woman had been assaulted by a construction worker and later sent home by the university authorities. The student further claimed that the woman’s roommate subsequently informed other students that she had died by suicide.

These claims have not been independently confirmed by police.

Deputy Inspector General of Jalandhar Range Naveen Singla said students had claimed that a girl in a hostel had been sexually assaulted around three days earlier and had since returned home. Police registered a case based on that statement, according to the report.

Earlier, Kapurthala Senior Superintendent of Police Gaurav Toora said police had no information about any such crime being reported to them.

Protests turn violent

The protests at LPU escalated, with students vandalising parts of the campus and setting some objects and sections of the building on fire.

Videos showed groups of students protesting and demanding justice. Some students also damaged window panes and flower pots, while a group blocked the Jalandhar-Phagwara national highway, resulting in significant traffic disruption.

Police said an assessment of the property damage was underway and that legal action would follow.

LPU separately urged students to ignore what it described as false and misleading rumours and asked them to remain inside their hostels or residences and avoid involvement in the unrest.

The developments have left the central allegation unresolved, with police investigation continuing and the university maintaining that the claims circulating on social media were rumours.

Continue Reading

India News

3-day bank strike deferred after talks between unions, banks’ association

The three-day nationwide bank strike scheduled to begin on Monday has been deferred after the United Forum of Bank Unions held talks with the Indian Banks’ Association.

Published

on

Bank Strike

The three-day nationwide bank strike scheduled to begin on Monday has been deferred following a meeting between the United Forum of Bank Unions (UFBU) and the Indian Banks’ Association (IBA) on Sunday night.

The development came after the two sides held talks ahead of the planned strike, which was expected to affect banking operations across the country.

The UFBU, an umbrella forum representing bank unions, had called for the three-day nationwide strike. The action was scheduled to begin on September 28.

Bank strike deferred after Sunday meeting

The decision to defer the strike followed an eleventh-hour meeting between representatives of the UFBU and the IBA on Sunday night.

The proposed strike had raised concerns about disruption to banking services for millions of customers. With the strike now deferred, the immediate three-day disruption that was scheduled to begin Monday will not take place as planned.

The development comes after earlier efforts by the government and bank managements to persuade the unions to defer the strike. The unions had been seeking, among other demands, the introduction of a five-day banking system.

What were the bank unions demanding?

The UFBU’s demands included the introduction of five-day banking. Other issues raised by the unions included improvements in pension-related matters, a uniform dearness allowance formula for pensioners and an option for employees covered under the National Pension System to move to the old pension scheme.

The proposed strike had been scheduled for September 28, 29 and 30. The timing had also raised concerns because September 26 and 27 were a Saturday and Sunday, respectively, while September 30 coincides with the half-yearly closing of banks.

Continue Reading

India News

LPU students protest over reported rape allegation, police call it rumour

Students at Lovely Professional University protested over a reported rape allegation involving a worker, with police describing the claim as a rumour.

Published

on

Students of Lovely Professional University (LPU) in Punjab staged a protest after an allegation involving the reported rape of a student by a worker at the university surfaced.

The protest led to disruption around the university, with students taking to the streets and blocking the Jalandhar-Phagwara National Highway, according to the report.

The allegation triggered anger among students, who demanded action over the reported incident.

Police describe rape claim as rumour

Police, however, described the rape claim as a rumour, indicating that the allegation had not been established as a confirmed incident.

The distinction is important because the reported sexual assault allegation should not be treated as a confirmed rape unless investigators or other authoritative sources establish that fact.

The protests nevertheless continued as students sought clarity and action over the issue.

Protest disrupts traffic

The student demonstration also affected traffic on the Jalandhar-Phagwara National Highway. The protest brought attention to the allegations and the concerns being raised by students at the university.

With police calling the claim a rumour, further verification and investigation would be necessary to establish what actually happened.

Continue Reading

Trending

© Copyright 2022 APNLIVE.com