Mudda discusses ways to reduce accidents, fault of the transport department, railway department, school and the driver, says panellist
In a shocking accident, 13 children have been killed and eight more injured after a speeding train crashed into a school van today at an unmanned crossing in Uttar Pradesh’s Kushinagar. An official told NDTV that a Gate Mitra, who alerts commuters about approaching trains at crossings, tried to stop the van but it was too late.
The chief minister of the state said: “I am told that the school van driver was wearing earphones while driving… this is a case of pure negligence… An inquiry has been ordered and based on the investigation; the guilty will face the most severe punishment.”
Thursday’s edition of Mudda, APN’s daily current affairs show discussed the issue. Moderated by Anant Tyagi, the guests were BJP spokesperson Rakesh Tripathi, Congress spokesperson Surendra Rajput, former member of Railway Board Satish Mohan Vaishya, educationist Dr Manjula Upadhyay, member of Parents’ Association Noida Niti Srivastava, Samajwadi Party spokesperson Manoj Yadav and APN consulting editor Govind Pant Raju.
Rakesh Tripathi asked not to politicise the issue. He said: “I express my grief for the children who died in the family members. I won’t deny our shortcomings which led to the incident. The state government and the railway ministry have asked for an inquiry. There are thousands of crossings in the country which are unmanned at present. We are working towards it. Also, if the driver was not wearing earphones, the accident might have been avoided.”
Surendra Rajput raised some questions to the Central and state government. He said: “Our Prime Minister Narendra Modi is talking about constructing bullet trains and defence industrial corridors but who will make the railways safe? There are some 17,000 unmanned railway crossings in the country… It is the responsibility of the local authorities to ensure the safety of school bus and vans.”
Manoj Yadav said it is the fault of the transport department, railway department, school and the driver. He further said that the whole system should be revised and a special team should be constituted which will look into the safety of school vans and bus.
Govind Pant Raju said that the Central government had said in previous budgets that within two years it will do away with all the unmanned crossings in the country but nothing has been done yet. He added: “The same thing was said in Budget 2018 too. Gate Mitra will be put in place who will alert everyone. Where are they? It was also said that there will be multiple crossing board which will give the signal from far. It was also stated that a chip made by ISRO, Gagan chip, will be used in the engines which will alert the trains whenever someone is crossing so that they can slow down or stop. Where are these? These incidents are recurring. In July last year 19 children had died in an accident at the crossing in Telengana… Also, a driver of a school vehicle is under pressure to reach on time. So, to meet the time target the drivers often drive carelessly. This has been mentioned in railway enquiry reports earlier. They should also be given some kinds of training.”
Manjula Upadhyay said these accidents can happen again if the driver is not responsible and trained. She further said that the schools should not so strict that if a child is five minutes late he/she would not be allowed inside the gate.
Niti Srivastava said we should not start a blame game now. She said: “Such accidents will happen in future too so we should now see what can be done to prevent them.”
Satish Mohan Vaishya said we should discuss who has what responsibilities and if they have carried it out successfully. He said: “In this case, it was the responsibility of the school to ensure the children’s safety. The school should test and train the drivers. And, it is the responsibility of the railway authorities to ensure the safety of the roads. The roads should be such made that people coming from both sides should be able to see if any vehicle is coming.” When asked his comments on the issue of unmanned crossings, he said that those who are talking about it don’t have any idea how much it costs to improve such situations. To this, Raju said such comments coming from member (former) of a railway board only prove how irresponsible they are. He said: “Everything costs money. The government should complete the mission in phases.”
—Compiled by Usha Rani Das