English हिन्दी
Connect with us

India News

Can Tharoor be a PM alternative for Congress?

Published

on

Can Tharoor be a PM alternative for Congress?

[vc_row][vc_column][vc_column_text]An online petition on these lines might have set the cat among the Congress coterie mice

~By Meha Mathur[/vc_column_text][vc_column_text]The election results for the Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand assemblies have cemented Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s stature as the tallest national leader and at the same time eclipsed all other leaders.

None can come close to him in mass following, even opposition leaders concede. So much so that National Conference leader Omar Abdullah tweeted: “In a nutshell there is no leader today with a pan-India acceptability who can take on Modi and the BJP in 2019. At this rate we might as well forget 2019 and start planning/hoping for 2024,”

And Congress stalwart P Chidambaram admitted: “The elections today have clearly established that the most dominant political figure in India is Prime Minister Modi. And he has a pan-India appeal.” For this, he has been rebuked by the top Congress leadership.

Now that Rahul Gandhi has clearly failed to garner votes for his party – the victory in Punjab was more a result of the personal charisma of Captain Amarinder Singh, and had little to do with the Nehru-Gandhi family — the desperation to find a viable competitor to Modi is gaining ground. And a petition on Change.org—an online petition portal, mobilising opinion globally on social, developmental and political issues—is a step in that direction. With more than 10,000 signatures already, this petition wants Congress MP from Thiruvananthapuram, Shashi Tharoor, to be Congress’ prime ministerial face for the 2019 elections.

The petition, addressed to President Indian National Congress, All India Congress Committee and the UPA, states: “In another two years’ time India, the largest democracy of the world will face another national election. Success of a democratic country requires a strong public interest-based opposition led by a visionary leader capable of Prime Ministership…

“Dr Shashi Tharoor is a man well qualified, with deep knowledge of international and national issues, who can connect with the people of India and with world leaders. We nominate Dr Shashi Tharoor to be the Prime Ministerial candidate of UPA in the run up to 2019.

“In best interest of the World’s Largest Democracy and to rejuvenate the opposition,” says the petitioner, hailing from Thiruvanthapuram, identifying himself as just Paul.

Among the positives that the petition lists are:

  • After retirement, he (Tharoor) chose to serve India and joined Indian politics; did not choose (the) UK/US citizenship option available since he was born in United Kingdom and worked in UN@NYC for long.
  • He chose to be elected by the people, not the soft entry option through Rajya Sabha
  • Initiated development activities in his first 5-year term as MP that won wide acclaim
  • Won again in 2014 against the anti-incumbent wave lashing the country.
  • Available throughout the year to his constituents in Thiruvananthapuram

This says a lot about Tharoor’s credentials.  The erudite and suave UN official first came to light when he wrote The Great Indian Novel in 1989, in which he had drawn parallels between The Mahabharata and the Independence Movement and early years of Independent India. In the novel, he had ripped apart the Gandhi-Nehru legacy, likening Bhishma to Mahatma Gandhi, Dhritarashtra to Nehru and Duryodhana to Indira Gandhi.

He contested for the post of UN Secretary General in 2006, but lost to Ban Ki-moon. He then ventured into Indian politics, and was surprisingly lapped up by the Congress despite the scathing novel. He contested and won from the parliamentary constituency of Thiruvananthapuram in the 2009 Lok Sabha elections.

He endeared himself to the Twitterati and ruffled quite a few feathers with his tweets during his stint in the Ministry of External Affairs.

The Congress leader has been mired in controversy following the death of his wife Sunanda Pushkar in suspicious circumstances in January 2014, but has still kept himself afloat, winning his Thiruvananthapuram seat even in the otherwise disastrous Lok Sabha elections in 2014.

Earlier, in 2010, he had to step down as Minister of State for External Affairs following a cricket (IPL) scandal—he was working as an advisor to a cricket consortium in which his wife Sunanda Pushkar had the main stake.

Despite the political and personal setbacks, Tharoor has held his ground in academic and intellectual circles. His arguments at the Oxford Union debate in 2015, wherein he argued that Britain owes India an apology for mercilessly exploiting the colony for 200 years, and the follow-up book that he wrote An Era of Darkness, in which he elaborated his argument, have caught attention of social media globally.

The question is, is he a match for Modi? Would his erudition add anything to his charisma, vis-a-vis the ordinary Indian? Well, in terms of statesmanship, definitely. An urbane, articulate politician, with a global appeal, he definitely makes the cut. His addresses are well reasoned, well researched, factually sound, and, at the same time, carry an emotional appeal. His understanding of historical and political processes lends to his inclusive approach, in contrast to the divisive approach of Modi.

But the statesmanship and erudition might still not make him a match for Modi, who has his ears and nose to the ground, who has a grand vision for country, even if it’s problematic as far as social cohesion and environmental implications are concerned. Modi has specifically focused on big infrastructure projects, down to the small details; job generation, skills development, and the voter has bought that vision. His comment on “Harvard versus hard work” has appealed to the common sensibilities.

If Tharoor has an international standing, thanks to his long years with the UN, Modi has captured international imagination notches higher and has also ingratiated himself to the world leaders on the strength of economic hardsell, after facing years of boycott.

The murky murder case of Sunanda Pushkar also hangs like an albatross around Tharoor’s neck. Strangely for a person of secular credentials, Tharoor had lapped up the first opportunity to praise Modi as an “avatar of modernity” in June 2014, soon after Modi had taken over as PM. What was the hurry, we wonder. Modi, in turn, showered praise on Tharoor in 2015, following his Oxford speech. So far, it’s congenial. But will the bonhomie remain if the demand for Tharoor as PM candidate gains strength?

Of course, he has openly criticised the communal stance of Modi at several points of time. When the assembly election results were announced, Tharoor commented: “When a ruling party in a state has not even one member from a substantial minority, that to my mind is injustice.”

The biggest stumbling block in Tharoor’s ascendency will be the party high command’s approach, in all likelihood. It’s a tired leadership with a lackadaisical Rahul-Priyanka duo hitting the campaign trail each time (mother Sonia being unwell), but Congress has become so entrenched in family leadership that no leader can raise doubts on leadership. There have been outsiders no doubt. The family did allow Manmohan Singh to run the show, but it was Sonia who continued to wield final authority.

Now, even if the family is willing to open the gates to outsiders again, will Tharoor be able to break the queue? Or will the baton pass on to the more hardened Chidambaram?[/vc_column_text][/vc_column][/vc_row]

India News

CJP leaders Saurav Das, Ashutosh Ranka, Ajinkya Shinde sent to 5-day judicial custody

Three CJP leaders, Saurav Das, Ashutosh Ranka and Ajinkya Shinde, were placed under preventive arrest following a protest at Delhi’s Jantar Mantar over Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar.

Published

on

Three leaders of the Cockroach Janata Party (CJP) — Saurav Das, Ashutosh Ranka and Ajinkya Shinde — have been placed under preventive arrest in connection with a protest at Delhi’s Jantar Mantar, where demonstrators demanded the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar.

The three were detained early Tuesday after crossing police barricades and entering Jantar Mantar, which was recently removed from the list of designated protest venues. A case was registered against them over their alleged actions.

According to the police case, the charges include trespassing, violation of a bond, and obstructing a public official from performing official duties.

The three leaders were produced before a Special Court of the Executive Magistrate on Wednesday and could be sent to judicial custody at Tihar Jail.

Why CJP leaders protested at Jantar Mantar

The protest comes amid demonstrations by the CJP and opposition groups over alleged irregularities in the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.

The protesters were demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. The controversy centres on allegations concerning the electoral roll revision exercise, which the Election Commission and the BJP have denied.

Jantar Mantar was recently removed from the list of designated protest venues in Delhi. The change followed an order naming alternative locations for demonstrations, prompting criticism from groups that want to hold protests at the established site.

CJP legal team raises concerns over detention

Ratna Singh, head of the CJP legal team, said in a post on X that Delhi Police had arrested Saurav Das, Ashutosh Ranka and Ajinkya Shinde at Parliament Street Police Station in connection with the Jantar Mantar case.

Singh alleged that the three were brought to the police station in a private van at around 3 am and were not allowed to meet their lawyers until late at night.

She also raised concerns about the legal process and the possibility of the leaders being sent to judicial custody.

The allegations regarding access to legal counsel were made by the CJP legal team and should be distinguished from the charges registered by the police.

The arrests mark another development in the ongoing dispute over protests at Jantar Mantar and the CJP’s campaign against the Chief Election Commissioner over the SIR exercise.

Continue Reading

India News

BJP focuses on religion as opposition pushes BDM strategy in UP

The BJP is emphasising religious issues ahead of the Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections, while opposition parties are seeking to consolidate Backward, Dalit and Minority voters. Recent exchanges involving Yogi Adityanath, Akhilesh Yadav and Asaduddin Owaisi have added to the political contest over the state’s electoral narrative.

Published

on

Ahead of the 2027 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections, the BJP is emphasising religious issues, while opposition parties are seeking to build a coalition of Backward, Dalit and Minority voters. The competing approaches have brought caste representation and religious messaging to the forefront of the state’s political discourse.

Recent temple-related controversies in Kashi, Ayodhya, Mathura and Sambhal have brought religious messaging back into the political conversation. The developments have also coincided with exchanges between Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath and Samajwadi Party chief Akhilesh Yadav over possible electoral contests.

Yogi Adityanath, Akhilesh Yadav trade election challenges

The latest round of political exchanges followed Yogi Adityanath’s invocation of the “80-20” formula during the Rajya Sabha election. Akhilesh Yadav subsequently challenged the Chief Minister to contest from Ayodhya.

During his visit to Ayodhya, the Samajwadi Party president attended a Bhagwat Katha but did not visit the Ram Mandir for darshan. His visit, during which he attended a Bhagwat Katha but did not visit the Ram Mandir for darshan, became another point of political discussion.

The Chief Minister responded during a visit to Balrampur, asking Akhilesh Yadav to contest against him.

The exchanges continued as political leaders questioned the Samajwadi Party chief’s religious outreach. State minister Om Prakash Rajbhar asked why Yadav had not visited Mathura, while AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi challenged him to contest from Sambhal.

Responding to questions about the challenges, Akhilesh Yadav said the Chief Minister does not decide which candidates the parties nominate.

At a press conference in Lucknow, Yadav also remarked, “What could be better than getting the Chief Minister’s chair without even contesting the election?” His comment suggested that Adityanath might not contest the Assembly elections.

Adityanath, meanwhile, said he was pleased to have several options available to him.

BJP works on its own caste coalition

Alongside its emphasis on religious issues, the BJP is also seeking to broaden its social support base through caste representation.

During the Rajya Sabha elections, the party fielded three candidates from Backward Classes, two Dalits, two Brahmins and one Rajput. The Backward Class candidates included representatives of the Pal, Kurmi and Lodh communities.

The report describes the BJP’s selection of candidates from the Sonkar and Rawat communities as an attempt to attract support among the Gaur and Jatav Dalit vote banks. Its selection of two Brahmins and one Rajput was also part of its outreach to upper-caste voters.

These choices reflect the BJP’s efforts to build a social coalition that extends beyond its religious messaging as the state approaches the next Assembly election.

Akhilesh Yadav balances caste outreach with temple politics

The Samajwadi Party is also combining its BDM approach with religious outreach, described in the report as “soft Hindutva”.

Akhilesh Yadav is overseeing the construction of the Kedareshwar Temple in Etawah. When questioned about not visiting the Ram Mandir during his Ayodhya trip, he said he was waiting for the temple’s “Pran Pratishtha”, or consecration ceremony, implying that the ceremony held in 2024 did not count.

Yadav has also raised the issue of alleged theft of offerings at the Ram Temple, a move the report interprets as an attempt to appeal to Hindu voters.

The competing strategies indicate that caste representation, religious issues and temple-related controversies are all featuring in political messaging ahead of the 2027 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections.

Continue Reading

India News

L Murugan quits Union ministry to strengthen BJP in Tamil Nadu

L Murugan has resigned from his Union ministerial post and Rajya Sabha membership, saying he wants to return to grassroots politics and dedicate himself to strengthening the BJP in Tamil Nadu before the 2029 Lok Sabha elections.

Published

on

L Murugan

L Murugan has resigned from his position as Union Minister of State and his Rajya Sabha membership, saying he wants to return to grassroots politics and work towards strengthening the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in Tamil Nadu ahead of the 2029 Lok Sabha elections.

Murugan, who held the portfolios of Information and Broadcasting and Parliamentary Affairs, announced his decision in a post on X on Tuesday, October 13. He described his time in the Union government under Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s leadership as a great honour and said he wanted to devote himself full-time to the party’s work in Tamil Nadu.

L Murugan says he wants to return to grassroots politics

In his post, Murugan expressed gratitude for the opportunity to serve in the Union Council of Ministers and highlighted his background as the son of daily-wage labourers.

He said he now wished to return to the grassroots, stand alongside BJP workers and dedicate his time to strengthening the party in Tamil Nadu before the next Lok Sabha elections.

Murugan’s stated objective is to help expand the BJP’s presence in the state and contribute to the party’s performance in the 2029 general elections.

Murugan’s resignation comes amid Cabinet reshuffle speculation

His decision comes amid speculation about a possible reshuffle in the Union government. The discussion gained momentum after several Rajya Sabha MPs and ministers, including Petroleum Minister Hardeep Singh Puri, were not renominated.

However, the report does not establish that the speculation about a Cabinet reshuffle was the reason for Murugan’s resignation. His publicly stated reason was his desire to return to grassroots work and strengthen the BJP in Tamil Nadu.

Murugan thanks PM Modi for the opportunity to serve

Murugan described serving India and Tamil Nadu under Modi’s leadership as one of the greatest privileges of his life. He also referred to his journey from a family of daily-wage labourers to the Union Council of Ministers.

His announcement places his immediate political focus on Tamil Nadu, with the BJP’s preparations for the 2029 Lok Sabha elections forming a central part of his stated plans.

Continue Reading

Trending

© Copyright 2022 APNLIVE.com