English हिन्दी
Connect with us

India News

SC allows the terminally ill or comatose people the right to die

Published

on

SC allows the terminally ill or comatose people the right to die

The Supreme Court has allowed passive euthanasia in the country.

In a unanimous order on Friday, March 9, a five judge Constitution bench headed by Chief Justice of India (CJI) Dipak Misra recognised “living will” and laid down guidelines for its execution.

The SC bench, also comprising Justices AK Sikri, AM Khanwilkar, DY Chandrachud and Ashok Bhushan, said that the guidelines will be in force till legislation on the same is passed by Parliament.

The judges, who wrote four separate judgments expressing their views, were unanimous on allowing passive euthanasia and advance directives.

A ‘living will’ is made by a person, in a healthy, normal state of mind, specifying – for a situation when he/she is no longer able to express informed consent – whether or not he/she be kept alive purely on an artificial life support system in case of terminal illness or when in an irreversible vegetative state.

An advance directive is a document that enables competent persons to exercise their right to direct medical treatments in the event that they lose their decision making capacity. American Medical Association says there are two categories of advance directives: (1) a living will, which indicates the types of treatment that an individual wishes to receive or forgo under specified circumstances, and (2) a durable power of attorney for health care, which designates a proxy to make treatment decisions.

Passive euthanasia entails withdrawing artificial life support causing the death of a person who is in a permanent vegetative state, with no chance of recovery.

The court said advance directives for terminally-ill patients could be issued and executed by the next friend or relatives of the person after which a medical board would consider it, reported news agency PTI.

The court’s ruling came on a petition seeking recognition of a living will so that an individual could exercise the right to refuse medical treatment at a terminally ill stage of life.

While the Centre was in agreement on the question of allowing passive euthanasia, it opposed the concept of living will. Additional solicitor general PS Narasimha, representing the centre, told the court that consent for removal of artificial support may not be an informed one and could be misused in cases of the elderly.

He added that the government had already accepted the apex court’s ruling in the landmark Aruna Shanbaug case on 11 March 2011, which held that a specific category of relatives could seek permission from the court to opt for passive euthanasia on behalf of the person in cases of a terminally ill patient.

The apex court had ruled that such a request would have to be vetted by a medical board on the basis of which the concerned high court would decide whether to permit withdrawal of life support system or not.

On January 15, 2016, the Centre had said the 241st report of the Law Commission stated that passive euthanasia should be allowed with certain safeguards and there was also a proposed law — Medical Treatment of Terminally Ill Patient (Protection of Patients and Medical Practitioners) Bill, 2006.

The fundamental right to a “meaningful existence” includes a person’s choice to die without suffering, the apex court held on Friday.

The CJI’s judgment said the heart of the matter is whether law permits the acceleration of death without suffering.

Chief Justice Dipak Misra spoke about how societal pressure and fear of criminal liability by relatives and medical doctors ultimately led to the suffering and the undignified death of the patient.

The court said it was time to dispense with such shared suffering and sense of guilt and face reality. Doctors who attend the terminally-ill are under pressure and dither in letting the patient go, apprehending criminal liability and fear of being drawn into the “vortex” of a possible family struggle for inheritance.

Chief Justice Misra, in a common judgment with Justice AM Khanwilkar, said it was time to “alleviate the agony of an individual” and stand by his right to a dignified passing. A dignified death should follow a meaningful existence, the five-judge Bench agreed in a unanimous voice.

The Chief Justice’s judgment includes specific guidelines to test the validity of a living will, by whom it should be certified, when and how it should come into effect, etc. The guidelines also cover a situation where there is no living will and how to approach a plea for passive euthanasia.

Justice AK Sikri, in his separate opinion, said though religion, morality, philosophy, law and society share equally strong and conflicting opinions about whether right to life includes right to death, they all agree that a person should die with dignity.

Hence, the court, Justice Sikri said, is rightly in favour of the right to die with dignity.

Justice Sikri said an advance directive or living will from a patient to stop medical treatment at a particular stage — “particularly when he is brain dead or clinically dead or not revivable” — quells apprehensions of future regret for relatives and criminal action against doctors.

In a separate opinion, Justice Chandrachud observed that modern medical science should balance its quest to prolong life with the need to provide patients quality of life. One is meaningless without the other, Justice Chandrachud observed.

Justice Chandrachud said, “Life and death are inseparable. Every moment our bodies undergo change… life is not disconnected from death. Dying is a part of the process of living.”

Justice Chandrachud said the issue of death and when to die transcends the boundaries of law, but the court has intervened because it also concerns the liberty and autonomy of the individual.

He read from his judgment that the sanctity of life includes the dignity and autonomy of the individual. He said the search for a meaningful existence, the pursuit of happiness includes the exercise of free will.

“Free will includes the right of a person to refuse medical treatment,” Justice Chandrachud observed.

A person need not give any reasons nor is he answerable to any authority on why he should write an advanced directive.

But the judge held that active euthanasia is unlawful.

For this reason, he said the reasons given by a two-judge Bench of the Supreme Court in the Aruna Shanbaug case allowing passive euthanasia are “flawed” as the convoluted procedure to get a go-ahead for passive euthanasia makes the dignity of a dying person dependent on the whims and will of third parties.

“To deprive a person dignity at the end of life is to deprive him of a meaningful existence,” Justice Chandrachud read from his opinion he shared with Justice Ashok Bhushan.

Other countries where euthanasia is permitted

While euthanasia is still illegal in most parts of the United States, the doctors are allowed to prescribe lethal doses of medicine to terminally ill patients in five state — Washington DC, California, Colorado, Oregon and Vermont. Oregon was the first US state to legalise “assisted suicide”.  Australia has a system of ‘advance directive’ to allow citizens to decide how they would like to be treated in future, if they are incompetent to make a decision at that point. Euthanasia, in varying forms, is permitted in Belgium, Canada, and Sweden.

India News

Azam Khan walks out of jail after getting interim bail in money laundering case

Samajwadi Party leader Azam Khan walked out of Dasna jail after completing bail formalities in the money-laundering case filed by the Enforcement Directorate.

Published

on

Azam Khan

Samajwadi Party leader Azam Khan walked out of Dasna jail in Ghaziabad on Wednesday after completing the formalities for his release on interim bail in a money-laundering case filed by the Enforcement Directorate.

The Allahabad High Court had granted the 78-year-old politician interim bail on Tuesday. The court said there appeared to have been non-compliance with mandatory provisions governing his arrest under Article 22(1) of the Constitution and Section 19 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA).

Khan was arrested by the ED on October 31, shortly after he had stepped out of Rampur district jail on bail in another case. He was subsequently lodged in Dasna jail.

Why Azam Khan got interim bail

The Allahabad High Court’s order came after Khan challenged his arrest and subsequent custody in the ED case.

The court observed prima facie that the mandatory procedure under Article 22(1) and Section 19 of the PMLA had not been strictly followed at the time of his arrest. It also noted concerns over whether the grounds of arrest had been supplied to Khan in writing before he was produced for remand.

The court directed his release on a personal bond with two sureties of an equal amount, subject to the satisfaction of the Chief Judicial Magistrate in Ghaziabad. The next hearing in the case is scheduled for December 10.

Supreme Court refuses to stay interim bail

The ED subsequently approached the Supreme Court challenging the High Court’s interim bail order.

On Wednesday, the Supreme Court refused to stay Khan’s release on interim bail. The bench said the ED’s challenge would be listed for hearing on Thursday, November 19.

What is the money laundering case against Azam Khan?

The ED’s investigation is linked to the Maulana Mohammad Ali Jauhar Trust and allegations concerning government funds, land acquisition and the construction of Mohammad Ali Jauhar University in Rampur. Khan founded and controls the trust and is the honorary chancellor of the university.

The ED had arrested Khan under the PMLA on October 31 and sent him to judicial custody. The agency’s investigation was initiated in connection with multiple FIRs registered by Uttar Pradesh Police in 2019 over alleged forcible occupation of agricultural land for the university.

The interim bail order provides Khan temporary relief in the money-laundering case; it does not amount to an acquittal or a final decision on the allegations against him.

Continue Reading

India News

Massive fire breaks out at Kanpur chemical factory, explosions reported

A massive fire erupted at a chemical factory in Kanpur’s Ruma industrial area, triggering repeated explosions and prompting the evacuation of nearby workers and residents.

Published

on

A major fire broke out at a chemical factory in Kanpur’s Ruma area late Tuesday, with repeated explosions inside the plant making it difficult for firefighters to reach the site.

The fire occurred at the Nicholas Pigments and Inks factory in the UPSIDC Industrial Area behind KIT College, under the jurisdiction of Maharajpur police station. Multiple fire engines and rescue teams were deployed as the blaze continued to spread. 

Nearby areas evacuated as fire spreads

Police and fire personnel cordoned off the area around the factory as a precaution. Workers from nearby factories were evacuated and moved roughly one kilometre away from the site.

Residents in the surrounding area were also asked to leave their homes as authorities responded to the fire and the explosions.

The flames could reportedly be seen from several kilometres away, highlighting the scale of the blaze.

Firefighters struggle to approach plant

Repeated explosions inside the chemical factory prevented firefighters from directly approaching the affected plant. Teams instead attempted to tackle the fire from the roof of a neighbouring factory.

Fire engines and rescue personnel from different parts of Kanpur were sent to the location as efforts continued to bring the blaze under control. 

The cause of the fire was not immediately established and was being investigated.

No casualties reported so far

According to the report, no work was underway at the affected plant when the fire broke out, and no casualties had been reported at the time of reporting.

Authorities continued firefighting operations at the site while maintaining restrictions around the affected area because of the ongoing risk from the fire and explosions.

Continue Reading

India News

Rahul Gandhi shares Shiva-Parvati image after BJP mocks Papa’s lap remark

Rahul Gandhi responded to BJP criticism of his remarks about Sonia and Rajiv Gandhi by sharing an image of Lord Shiva and Goddess Parvati and speaking about love and belonging.

Published

on

Rahul-Gandhi

Congress leader and Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi on Tuesday responded to criticism from the BJP over his remarks about the relationship between his parents, Sonia Gandhi and former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi.

Rahul Gandhi shared an image depicting Lord Shiva and Goddess Parvati in an affectionate embrace and wrote about love, saying that fear, anger and hatred prevent BJP and RSS supporters from experiencing and expressing it.

He said it was his duty, as a “true Hindu”, to help free people from what he described as a “web” of fear, anger and hatred. He ended the post with the words “Satyam Shivam Sundaram.”

What Rahul Gandhi said in his post

In his post on X, Rahul Gandhi said that fear, anger and hatred had created a barrier in the hearts of BJP and RSS supporters.

He said this prevented them from experiencing and expressing love and added that he wanted them to experience the “beauty and joy of love and belonging”.

The post came a day after Rahul Gandhi spoke at the launch of Sonia Gandhi’s memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love, in New Delhi.

BJP targets Rahul Gandhi over Sonia-Rajiv anecdote

At the memoir launch on Monday, Rahul Gandhi spoke about the affection between his parents and recalled that his mother would sit on his father’s lap during family meals.

He said he had assumed this was normal while growing up and was surprised when he visited friends’ homes and found that their parents did not behave similarly.

Rahul also told his mother that Rajiv Gandhi had loved her and that he was proud of her.

The remarks drew criticism from BJP leaders, including Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma.

Sarma took a swipe at Rahul Gandhi while addressing Sonia Gandhi and said Rahul’s comments had caused embarrassment on the occasion of her memoir launch.

Himanta Sarma reacts to Shiva-Parvati post

Rahul Gandhi’s subsequent Shiva-Parvati post also drew a response from Himanta Biswa Sarma.

Sarma criticised the use of the image and said portraying mortals as Shiva and Parvati was not devotion. He argued that no human being could be equated with God.

The exchange has turned Rahul Gandhi’s personal recollection about his parents at Sonia Gandhi’s memoir launch into a fresh political dispute between the Congress and BJP.

Continue Reading

Trending

© Copyright 2022 APNLIVE.com