Nothing punctures a propaganda blitz like criticism from insiders, present or past. The BJP has the mortification of such salvos from two such within the span of a week. One was from a youngster who worked on BJP’s election campaigns in several north-eastern states as part of Ram Madhav’s team, Shivam Shankar Singh; the other from a former aide of the now sidelined BJP veteran LK Advani who revived the BJP and made it a mainstream party.
The BJP would dismiss one as insignificant and immature and the other as irrelevant. It has earlier rejected criticism from its leaders like Arun Shourie, Yashwant Sinha and Shatrughan Sinha with the dubious claim that they were only voicing frustration at being denied a place in government rather than respond to specific points with facts.
But the ‘voices’ do indicate a disenchantment and disillusionment that would register in the minds of many others.
In the latest instance, reported news agency PTI, Sudheendra Kulkarni, speaking at a panel discussion in Mumbai on Monday, said India needs a leader who can solve “big problems” such as the Kashmir issue and therefore he would like to see Congress chief Rahul Gandhi as the future prime minister.
Listing disputes with Pakistan and China, he said Prime Minister Narendra Modi has “failed” to solve the big problems. He then praised Rahul Gandhi, saying he is a “leader with good heart”.
He said dialogue is the only solution to solve the long-standing dispute with Pakistan, and normalising ties with the neighbouring country is key to India becoming a great nation.
“We must state what is required for solving the problem with Pakistan. And which is why I made a suggestion that I would like to see Rahul Gandhi as future prime minister,” he said at the event organised by All India Professionals’ Congress.
The event was attended by senior Congress leader Salman Khurshid, whose book ‘Spectrum Politics’ was launched there.
Kulkarni added: “(Rahul Gandhi) is young and he is idealist. He is a man with compassion. No political leader in recent times had spoken the language of love, affection and compassion.” That was to contrast Rahul Gandhi’s approach with that of the BJP under Modi and Amit Shah who follow a confrontationist, no-quarter-given, fight to the finish policy.
Ahead of the 2019 general elections, Sudhendra Kulkarni said Rahul Gandhi should visit neighbouring countries such as Pakistan, China and Bangladesh and emerge with ideas to solve the “big problems”.
“Like Rajiv Gandhi did when he was in the opposition… He went to Afghanistan. Similarly, Rahul ji should go to Pakistan, China, Bangladesh and emerge as a leader with new ideas on how to solve big problems that Modi ji has failed to solve,” Mr Kulkarni said.
He described himself as a “well-wisher” of the Congress and pitched for a dialogue between the party and the RSS notwithstanding their differences.
A few days earlier, Shivam Shankar had written a detailed piece with the headline “Why I Am Resigning From the BJP” in the news portal TheWire. While acknowledging some of the achievements of Modi government, he had listed a number of failures in government and the vitiating the atmosphere in the country.
The BJP-RSS leadership would do well to take note of these voices, although it is doubtful there would be any attempt to address the most important, which are also the worst, aspects.