Congress MP Shashi Tharoor has highlighted the diplomatic and global significance of BRICS after senior party leader P Chidambaram questioned the tangible benefits India has received from recent meetings of the grouping.
Speaking ahead of the BRICS summit in Delhi, Tharoor described BRICS as an important platform for the Global South and said hosting the summit was a matter of prestige for India. He also acknowledged challenges within the grouping, including differences among member countries and India’s trade imbalance with BRICS nations.
What Shashi Tharoor said about BRICS benefits
Tharoor said BRICS provides an important platform for the Global South. He pointed out that the grouping has 11 countries representing a majority of the world’s population and 41% of global GDP.
According to Tharoor, the size and diversity of the grouping make it significant on the global stage. He said the platform should therefore be taken seriously by other countries.
He also highlighted the importance of India hosting the BRICS summit. Tharoor said the presence of several heads of state and government, along with observers attending at the presidential and prime ministerial level, was a matter of prestige for India.
He linked the summit to India’s diplomatic convening power, saying that its value extends beyond immediate outcomes.
Tharoor flags challenges for BRICS
While listing the benefits, Tharoor also acknowledged that BRICS faces several challenges.
One of the key issues, according to him, is the difficulty of reaching a common position on major international developments. He pointed to differences over the Iran war and the Russia-Ukraine conflict.
Tharoor noted that when BRICS foreign ministers met in New Delhi in May, the countries were unable to agree on a joint statement. India, as the chair, instead issued a chair’s declaration.
He said the ability of the grouping to reach consensus would remain an important challenge for diplomats.
India faces trade imbalance with BRICS countries
Tharoor also raised concerns about the economic side of BRICS.
He said trade among BRICS countries has been growing but argued that the trend has been disadvantageous for India. According to him, India’s exports to BRICS countries have declined while imports from those countries have increased.
This trade imbalance was presented as one of the practical concerns that India needs to consider while assessing its engagement with the grouping.
What P Chidambaram said about BRICS
Tharoor’s comments came a day after former Union minister and Congress leader P Chidambaram questioned the tangible benefits India has received from recent BRICS summits.
Chidambaram said he did not think the last two or three BRICS meetings had produced significant tangible benefits or results for India.
He also pointed out that India participates in several multilateral groupings, including BRICS, the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation, the G20 and the Quad, and questioned what concrete benefits the country had received from them.
The BJP criticised Chidambaram’s remarks and described him as part of the “naraaz phupha” group that, according to the party, could not accept India’s progress.
Why are BRICS benefits being debated?
The latest exchange highlights two sides of the BRICS debate.
Chidambaram has questioned whether the grouping has delivered enough concrete outcomes for India, while Tharoor has emphasised its diplomatic importance, its representation of the Global South and India’s ability to bring major countries together.
At the same time, Tharoor has acknowledged challenges related to consensus and India’s trade position within the grouping.