India’s new captain Shubman Gill faced criticism for his leadership in the first Test against England, where the visitors suffered a five-wicket defeat. Former England captain Nasser Hussain remarked that Gill lacked the commanding presence of predecessors Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli on the field.
Despite five Indian batsmen scoring centuries, England chased 371 in their fourth innings to claim a 1-0 lead in the five-match series. Gill, in his debut as Test captain following Rohit Sharma’s retirement, endured a challenging start. Hussain, speaking on Sky Sports, described Gill’s captaincy as “reactive rather than proactive.”
“He was finding his feet. Gill didn’t exude the same on-field authority as Rohit or Kohli. He seemed to follow the ball and react, rather than anticipate and lead,” Hussain observed. “With Rohit or Kohli, you instantly knew who was in charge. Here, it felt like captaincy by committee, with multiple voices influencing decisions.”
Hussain, however, attributed India’s loss to factors beyond Gill’s control—dropped catches and batting collapses. “The collapses are worrying. In India, spin-bowling all-rounders like Ravi Ashwin, Ravindra Jadeja, and Axar Patel have been exceptional. But in England, India still need a seam-bowling all-rounder who can bat. If they keep collapsing—6 for 31, 7 for 41—this series could end quickly,” said the former England batter, who played 96 Tests from 1990 to 2004.
Former India coach Ravi Shastri, in contrast, defended Gill’s performance. “The coaching staff must focus on the positives. Gill has done more than could be expected. He scored a century in his first Test as captain, and the dropped catches and collapses weren’t his fault,” Shastri said. Gill made 147 in India’s first innings total of 471 but managed only 8 in the second.
“This defeat will sting. India rarely squander such dominant positions. They had a chance to crush England and control the game. The tail needs more grit—they must value their wickets more,” Shastri added.
Shastri also urged that lead pacer Jasprit Bumrah, who took five wickets in England’s first innings, should play the second Test starting 2 July in Birmingham. “If rest was planned, reconsider. Without Bumrah, falling 2-0 behind could make this an uphill battle.” Bumrah, managing a recent back injury, intends to play only three of the five Tests.
Former England seamer Stuart Broad praised England’s resilience. “Winning a Test like this feels incredible, especially when India had multiple chances to seal it. England fought tirelessly. Ben Duckett was phenomenal, and this team keeps delivering remarkable chases.”