English हिन्दी
Connect with us

India News

Citing principle of fairness, SC awards farmers more compensation than they sought

Published

on

Citing principle of fairness, SC awards farmers more compensation than they sought

[vc_row][vc_column][vc_column_text]In a path-breaking judgment, SC hikes compensation sum from Rs 115 per square yard to Rs 297 per square yard

~By Sujit Bhar

In an extraordinary judgment, the Supreme Court on September 11 directed that some villagers in Uttar Pradesh, whose land had been acquired by the state at the rate of Rs 115 per square yard, actually deserved to be paid Rs 297 per square yard, even if the farmers had not demanded compensation at that rate.

In delivering this judgment – in the matter of Narendra & Ors. v State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors – the court made an  observation which should go down in history as a precedent as judgments come. The court observed that “the mere fact that the compensation which was claimed by some of the villagers was at lesser rate than the compensation which is ultimately determined to be fair compensation, should not be a ground to deny such persons appropriate and fair compensation on the ground that they claimed compensation at a lesser rate”.

The Allahabad High Court had granted compensation to the villagers – those whose land had been acquired by the state – at the rate of Rs 115 per square yard. However, the Supreme Court set aside this judgment and set the higher compensation limit, saying that the difference in compensation, along with other statutory benefits, was directed to be paid to them within a period of three months.

Why is this verdict special? That is because a fair consideration of a demand does not just look at the demand, but also to peripheral situations that exist, often beyond the field of view of the petitioner.

Justice is not a one-dimensional, monochromatic word. It encapsulates a philosophy that Plato gave birth to while considering the genesis of justice. Being fair is one way to describe it, but Plato, in using the Greek word “dikaisyne”, pushed it more towards “morality” or “righteousness”. While these, in ancient times, were the right duties of a man, they also take into consideration societal aspects of fairness and morality. If in one tradition honour killing is righteous and moral, it isn’t in another. That is a paradox that needs to be dealt with.

What Plato wanted to do was show that justice is the quality of soul, a lack of selfishness and a general belief that it was done for the general good. It would have had been difficult in a society where death for honour was a purely divine experience.

Over and above, societal expectations on compensation vary. How would a square yard of a person’s personal farmland, handed down through generations, and his or her only source of sustenance, be compensated? At stake is not only his income, but his/her very identity.

Those are philosophical considerations and the debate can be endless. In more prosaic terms, however, compensation is indemnification, payment of damages, making amends, that which is necessary to restore an injured party to his former position. Those are the legal peripherals, as per Black’s Law Dictionary. And in judging each and every aspect of that comes the question of morality. And that is where the Supreme Court judgement has scored high on principles. That is what makes this judgment extraordinary.

While it is common practice to assume that a demand has to be judged within the ambit of normal standards, it is also inferred that the demand can be considered as the upper limit in resolution of the debate. In this case, the top court went beyond that and assumed that the demands were probably not made with full knowledge of the market.  The apex court felt morally liable to adjudicate on moral guidelines.

The Indian Supreme Court deserves a big thank you for that.[/vc_column_text][/vc_column][/vc_row]

India News

Massive fire breaks out at Kanpur chemical factory, explosions reported

A massive fire erupted at a chemical factory in Kanpur’s Ruma industrial area, triggering repeated explosions and prompting the evacuation of nearby workers and residents.

Published

on

A major fire broke out at a chemical factory in Kanpur’s Ruma area late Tuesday, with repeated explosions inside the plant making it difficult for firefighters to reach the site.

The fire occurred at the Nicholas Pigments and Inks factory in the UPSIDC Industrial Area behind KIT College, under the jurisdiction of Maharajpur police station. Multiple fire engines and rescue teams were deployed as the blaze continued to spread. 

Nearby areas evacuated as fire spreads

Police and fire personnel cordoned off the area around the factory as a precaution. Workers from nearby factories were evacuated and moved roughly one kilometre away from the site.

Residents in the surrounding area were also asked to leave their homes as authorities responded to the fire and the explosions.

The flames could reportedly be seen from several kilometres away, highlighting the scale of the blaze.

Firefighters struggle to approach plant

Repeated explosions inside the chemical factory prevented firefighters from directly approaching the affected plant. Teams instead attempted to tackle the fire from the roof of a neighbouring factory.

Fire engines and rescue personnel from different parts of Kanpur were sent to the location as efforts continued to bring the blaze under control. 

The cause of the fire was not immediately established and was being investigated.

No casualties reported so far

According to the report, no work was underway at the affected plant when the fire broke out, and no casualties had been reported at the time of reporting.

Authorities continued firefighting operations at the site while maintaining restrictions around the affected area because of the ongoing risk from the fire and explosions.

Continue Reading

India News

Rahul Gandhi shares Shiva-Parvati image after BJP mocks Papa’s lap remark

Rahul Gandhi responded to BJP criticism of his remarks about Sonia and Rajiv Gandhi by sharing an image of Lord Shiva and Goddess Parvati and speaking about love and belonging.

Published

on

Rahul-Gandhi

Congress leader and Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi on Tuesday responded to criticism from the BJP over his remarks about the relationship between his parents, Sonia Gandhi and former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi.

Rahul Gandhi shared an image depicting Lord Shiva and Goddess Parvati in an affectionate embrace and wrote about love, saying that fear, anger and hatred prevent BJP and RSS supporters from experiencing and expressing it.

He said it was his duty, as a “true Hindu”, to help free people from what he described as a “web” of fear, anger and hatred. He ended the post with the words “Satyam Shivam Sundaram.”

What Rahul Gandhi said in his post

In his post on X, Rahul Gandhi said that fear, anger and hatred had created a barrier in the hearts of BJP and RSS supporters.

He said this prevented them from experiencing and expressing love and added that he wanted them to experience the “beauty and joy of love and belonging”.

The post came a day after Rahul Gandhi spoke at the launch of Sonia Gandhi’s memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love, in New Delhi.

BJP targets Rahul Gandhi over Sonia-Rajiv anecdote

At the memoir launch on Monday, Rahul Gandhi spoke about the affection between his parents and recalled that his mother would sit on his father’s lap during family meals.

He said he had assumed this was normal while growing up and was surprised when he visited friends’ homes and found that their parents did not behave similarly.

Rahul also told his mother that Rajiv Gandhi had loved her and that he was proud of her.

The remarks drew criticism from BJP leaders, including Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma.

Sarma took a swipe at Rahul Gandhi while addressing Sonia Gandhi and said Rahul’s comments had caused embarrassment on the occasion of her memoir launch.

Himanta Sarma reacts to Shiva-Parvati post

Rahul Gandhi’s subsequent Shiva-Parvati post also drew a response from Himanta Biswa Sarma.

Sarma criticised the use of the image and said portraying mortals as Shiva and Parvati was not devotion. He argued that no human being could be equated with God.

The exchange has turned Rahul Gandhi’s personal recollection about his parents at Sonia Gandhi’s memoir launch into a fresh political dispute between the Congress and BJP.

Continue Reading

India News

UP Chief Electoral Officer responds to CM Yogi Adityanath claim of 1.27 crore Hindu voters missing from rolls

Uttar Pradesh Chief Electoral Officer responds to CM Yogi Adityanath’s claim that 1.27 crore Hindu voters are missing from the electoral rolls.

Published

on

Yogi Adityanath

Uttar Pradesh Chief Electoral Officer Navdeep Rinwa has responded to Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath’s claim that 1.27 crore Hindu voters are missing from the state’s electoral rolls amid the Special Intensive Revision (SIR).

The CEO’s response centres on the fact that electoral rolls do not contain information about an elector’s religion. This means the official voter database does not provide a religion-wise count of voters.

What did Yogi Adityanath claim?

Yogi Adityanath had raised concerns over the number of voters allegedly missing from the electoral rolls during a discussion on the ongoing revision exercise in Uttar Pradesh.

The Chief Minister claimed that around 1.27 crore Hindu voters were missing from the rolls. He also raised questions over the gap between the state’s population and the number of voters currently reflected in the electoral database.

Yogi urged BJP workers and other party functionaries to coordinate with Booth Level Officers (BLOs) and work to ensure that eligible voters are included in the electoral rolls.

UP CEO’s response

Responding to the claim, UP Chief Electoral Officer Navdeep Rinwa said electoral rolls contain details of electors but do not record their religion.

As a result, the Election Commission’s voter database does not have a separate category showing how many Hindu voters are present or missing from the electoral rolls.

The clarification is significant because the figure cited by Yogi specifically refers to Hindu voters, while the electoral-roll data itself is not maintained on the basis of religion.

The issue comes amid UP’s SIR

The exchange comes amid the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls in Uttar Pradesh ahead of the 2027 Assembly election.

The revision process has become a major political issue in the state, with parties raising concerns over names being removed or excluded from voter lists and the Election Commission maintaining that the exercise is aimed at ensuring accurate electoral rolls.

The controversy over the 1.27 crore figure is therefore separate from the broader question of whether eligible voters’ names have been left out of the electoral rolls.

Why the CEO’s clarification matters

The UP CEO’s response does not amount to an assessment of whether the 1.27 crore figure is correct or incorrect. Instead, it points to a limitation in the electoral-roll data: voter lists do not identify electors by religion.

Therefore, a religion-specific figure for missing voters cannot be established from the electoral-roll database simply by looking at the official voter records.

The dispute over Yogi’s claim is likely to remain part of the wider political debate surrounding the voter-list revision in Uttar Pradesh ahead of the 2027 Assembly election.

Continue Reading

Trending

© Copyright 2022 APNLIVE.com