English हिन्दी
Connect with us

India News

In dissenting order, Justice BV Nagarathna calls demonetisation notification unlawful

The Supreme Court Constitution bench, with 4:1 majority, backed the notes ban decision by Central Government

Published

on

Justice BV Nagarathna

The Supreme Court has given its verdict on demonetisation. The Constitution Bench of the court with a 4:1 majority has upheld the decision of the Central Government to ban the notes of 500 and 1000 rupees six years ago. Along with this, the court has also dismissed all the 58 petitions. 4 judges have taken the decision by majority. At the same time, a judge has raised questions on demonetisation. While giving the verdict, the bench said that no error has been found in the notification of November 8, 2016 and all series of notes can be withdrawn.

Justice BV  Nagarathna’s opinion regarding demonetisation appeared different. She said that demonetisation of all series of notes at the behest of the central government is a far more serious issue than bank demonetisation. Therefore, it should be done first through executive notification and then through legislation. She further said that as per section 26(2), the proposal for demonetisation can come only from the Central Board of RBI.

Justice Nagarathna said the RBI did not apply an independent mind and only approved the Centre’s wish for demonetisation. She also said that a perusal of the records produced by the RBI shows that the entire exercise was done in just 24 hours due to the will of the Centre.

Justice Nagarathna said that in her considered view, action of demonetisation was unlawful but status quo ante could not be restored since it was in 2016. She also said that the demonetisation was an exercise of power, contrary to law, ergo unlawful.

Read Also: Demonetisation valid: Supreme Court Constitution Bench approves move to demonetize Rs 1000, Rs 500 notes

She continued by saying that the way it was carried out was illegal. According to the RBI Act, the board of the Reserve Bank of India should recommend demonetisation, however in this instance, the Centre addressed a letter to RBI on November 7 advising for such a decision, she said.

Additionally, Justice Nagarathna ruled that rather than an executive notification, a Parliamentary Act may have been used to start the demonetisation process, as it had in the past.

Phrases like “as requested by Centre Govt” suggest there was no independent application of mind by RBI, Justice Nagarathna observed after reviewing the documents and data that the Centre and RBI gave.

Delhi: Woman killed after car hits her and drags her for 4 km in Kanjhawala, CCTV footage goes viral| WATCH

14 coaches of Suryanagari Express derail in Rajasthan, 24 passengers injured, 12 trains diverted

India News

Union Minister Smriti Irani questions Rahul Gandhi’s love for Indian democracy over his boycott of the new Parliament inauguration

Irani questioned what kind of love it that massacred Sikhs(referring to the 1984-Anti Sikh riots)?

Published

on

Union Minister Smriti Irani questions Rahul Gandhi’s love for Indian democracy over his boycott of the new Parliament inauguration

Union Minister Smriti Irani tore apart Rahul Gandhi’s Mohabbat Ki Dukaan campaign, questioning his love for Indian democracy and the people of India.

Irani questioned what kind of love it that massacred Sikhs(referring to the 1984-Anti-Sikh riots)? She questioned, what kind of love was that insulted the Sengol(the golden stick, which was placed in the new Parliament by Prime Minister Narendra Modi)? She said she wanted to ask him about what kind of love was it that boycotted the inauguration of the new Parliament? Irani asked him to tell her what kind of love was it which was to be silent while the film The Kerala Story was released.

She said she could not understand what kind of love is it that shook hands and hugged those people who curse India or the concept of India.

Irani adding to her attack, said, Rahul Gandhi is only defaming India outside its national boundaries. During the press conference, she listed the achievements of the Modi-ruled Centre government in the last nine years.

She said, women are more protected today and cited the success of government programs like Beti Padhao and Beti Bachao. She hailed the government for its efforts of holistic development, talking about the government scheme of Sabka Saath and Sabka Vikas.

The Minister congratulated the people of India on the inauguration of the new parliament building. She stated it was the priority of the government to ensure that every class is assured that financial allocation is done for any class or community.

She said the figures themselves told the truth. She said that the Congress party, in its hunger for power, is using external forces which are hurting the Indian democracy.  

Continue Reading

India News

Fire at KGMU Lucknow’s under-construction hospital complex | Watch video

Lucknow has been in the news since yesterday over the shoot-out that took place at a Lucknow Court complex. In the shoot-out, gangster Mukhtar Ansari’s close associate Sanjeev Maheshwari alias Jeeva was shot dead.

Published

on

KGMU Lucknow

A massive fire broke out at an under construction complex of the King George Medical University(KGMU) hospital in Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh on Thursday.

The building which was ablaze, is meant to house the cardiology department.

As soon as the fire broke out, fire-fighting teams rushed to the spot. While, no casualties are being reported from the accident, the reason behind the ablaze is not yet ascertained.

Lucknow District Magistrate Suryapal Gangwar confirmed that there were no casualties as it was an under-construction facility.

KGMU is one of the eminent medical universities in India. It was set up in 1906, the idea of which was floated back in 1870 by the then Maharaja of Vizianagaram. The idea was put on hold due to lack of funds but later in 1905, George V inspired the idea of setting up the college.

Lucknow has been in the news since yesterday over the shoot-out that took place at a Lucknow Court complex. In the shoot-out, gangster Mukhtar Ansari’s close associate Sanjeev Maheshwari alias Jeeva was shot dead.

A man dressed as a lawyer entered the court complex and fired six rounds. In the incident, a 7-8 –year-old girl and a policeman were injured.

The accused has been identified as Vijay Yadav, a resident of UP’s Jaunpur district.

Earlier this morning, Uttar Pradesh CM Yogi Adityanath met with the injured girl to enquire about her well-being.  

The firing has yet again, raised questions on the law and order situation in UP as Jeeva was killed in the police custody.

The law and order of the state has been in question by the opposition parties since May, after the slain gangster-politician Atiq Ahmed and his brother Ashraf Ahmed were gunned down in a police custody inside a hospital complex in Prayagraj, while being taken for a medical examination.

Continue Reading

India News

Congress urges External Affairs Minister Jaishankar to take up Indira Gandhi assassination float with Canada

When the Foreign Minister was asked at a press conference, Jaishankar said, there was an issue about space which is given to extremists, separatists, and people who advocate violence.

Published

on

Congress urges External Affairs Minister Jaishankar to take up Indira Gandhi assassination float with Canada

The Congress on Thursday urged External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar to take up strongly with the Canadian authorities, a float depicting the assassination of former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi in a parade in Brampton, Canada.

When the Foreign Minister was asked at a press conference, Jaishankar said, there was an issue about space that is given to extremists, separatists, and people who advocate violence.

Jaishankar said he failed to understand why someone would do such a thing. He cited it as a clear case of vote bank politics. Condemning the incident, he said this was a clear issue of providing space to separatists, extremists, and to people who advocate violence. He further added it is not good for Canada and its relationship with India.    

The Canadian High Commissioner of India Cameron Mackay said he was shocked by the news of the event that celebrated the assassination of Indira Gandhi in his country. He further added, there is no place for hate or violence or act of glorification of violence in Canada, and he strongly condemned these activities.

Congress leader Milind Deora shared the video on Twitter, which showed a float depicting Gandhi’s assassination in a recent parade held in Brampton, Canada. He wrote, as an Indian, he was shocked seeing the video, the 5-km long parade portraying Gandhi’s killing.

Shashi Tharoor supported Deora and said he was completely right and such activities should be condemned with no politics involved.

Twitter users slamming the incident wrote it to be horrifying and painful. These things happening under the leadership of Justin Trudeau are shameful. A user said this was the force of hatred against which Rahul Gandhi has to fight. Another said, this to be really sad and the BJP government should take it up with the Canadian government.

Continue Reading

Trending

-->

© Copyright 2022 APNLIVE.com