English हिन्दी
Connect with us

India News

In dissenting order, Justice BV Nagarathna calls demonetisation notification unlawful

The Supreme Court Constitution bench, with 4:1 majority, backed the notes ban decision by Central Government

Published

on

Justice BV Nagarathna

The Supreme Court has given its verdict on demonetisation. The Constitution Bench of the court with a 4:1 majority has upheld the decision of the Central Government to ban the notes of 500 and 1000 rupees six years ago. Along with this, the court has also dismissed all the 58 petitions. 4 judges have taken the decision by majority. At the same time, a judge has raised questions on demonetisation. While giving the verdict, the bench said that no error has been found in the notification of November 8, 2016 and all series of notes can be withdrawn.

Justice BV  Nagarathna’s opinion regarding demonetisation appeared different. She said that demonetisation of all series of notes at the behest of the central government is a far more serious issue than bank demonetisation. Therefore, it should be done first through executive notification and then through legislation. She further said that as per section 26(2), the proposal for demonetisation can come only from the Central Board of RBI.

Justice Nagarathna said the RBI did not apply an independent mind and only approved the Centre’s wish for demonetisation. She also said that a perusal of the records produced by the RBI shows that the entire exercise was done in just 24 hours due to the will of the Centre.

Justice Nagarathna said that in her considered view, action of demonetisation was unlawful but status quo ante could not be restored since it was in 2016. She also said that the demonetisation was an exercise of power, contrary to law, ergo unlawful.

Read Also: Demonetisation valid: Supreme Court Constitution Bench approves move to demonetize Rs 1000, Rs 500 notes

She continued by saying that the way it was carried out was illegal. According to the RBI Act, the board of the Reserve Bank of India should recommend demonetisation, however in this instance, the Centre addressed a letter to RBI on November 7 advising for such a decision, she said.

Additionally, Justice Nagarathna ruled that rather than an executive notification, a Parliamentary Act may have been used to start the demonetisation process, as it had in the past.

Phrases like “as requested by Centre Govt” suggest there was no independent application of mind by RBI, Justice Nagarathna observed after reviewing the documents and data that the Centre and RBI gave.

Delhi: Woman killed after car hits her and drags her for 4 km in Kanjhawala, CCTV footage goes viral| WATCH

14 coaches of Suryanagari Express derail in Rajasthan, 24 passengers injured, 12 trains diverted

India News

Congress, BJP attack Bhagwant Mann over remarks on Punjab blasts

Congress and BJP have jointly criticised Punjab CM Bhagwant Mann after he linked recent blasts near defence sites to political motives, triggering a controversy.

Published

on

Bhagwant Mann

A political row has erupted in Punjab after Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann linked recent blast incidents to political motives, drawing sharp criticism from both the Congress and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).

The controversy follows two low-intensity explosions reported within a short span of time — one near the Border Security Force (BSF) headquarters in Jalandhar and another close to an army cantonment area in Amritsar. The incidents raised concerns over security, particularly given the sensitive nature of the locations.

In response, Mann suggested that the blasts could be part of a larger political strategy. His remarks triggered a strong backlash, with opposition parties accusing him of politicising a serious security issue.

Leaders from the Congress criticised the Chief Minister’s statement, calling it inappropriate and alleging that such comments undermine the gravity of the situation. They stressed that matters related to national security should be handled with caution and responsibility.

The BJP also joined the criticism, questioning the basis of Mann’s claims and urging the state government to focus on investigation and law enforcement instead of making political allegations.

The developments have led to an unusual moment where both Congress and BJP appear aligned in their criticism of the Aam Aadmi Party-led government in the state.

Meanwhile, the blasts themselves have intensified concerns over safety in border regions, with authorities continuing their investigation into the incidents. No casualties were reported, but the proximity to defence establishments has made the issue particularly sensitive.

The episode has further escalated political tensions in the state, with security and accountability emerging as key points of debate.

Continue Reading

India News

Himanta Biswa Sarma resigns as Assam chief minister, oath ceremony likely after May 11

Himanta Biswa Sarma resigns as Assam Chief Minister after BJP-led NDA’s victory. He will continue as caretaker CM until the new government is sworn in after May 11.

Published

on

Himanta sharma

Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma resigned from his post on Wednesday, paving the way for the formation of a new government after the BJP-led NDA secured a decisive victory in the 2026 Assembly elections.

Sarma submitted his resignation to Governor Lakshman Prasad Acharya at Lok Bhawan in Guwahati. The Governor accepted the resignation and asked him to continue as the caretaker Chief Minister until the new government takes charge.

The resignation comes after the NDA’s strong electoral performance, where the alliance won a clear majority in the 126-member Assembly, ensuring its return to power for another term.

Oath ceremony expected after May 11

Speaking to reporters after submitting his resignation, Sarma said the swearing-in ceremony for the new government is likely to be held after May 11.

He indicated that Prime Minister Narendra Modi has been invited to attend the ceremony but is unavailable until May 11, which has influenced the tentative schedule.

Decision on next chief minister soon

Sources suggest that central observers, including senior BJP leaders, are expected to arrive shortly to oversee the selection of the legislature party leader. The newly elected MLAs will then decide on the next Chief Minister.

Despite the formal resignation, party sources indicate that Sarma is likely to continue in the role for another term, given the BJP’s strong mandate in the state.

The move marks the beginning of the government formation process in Assam following the election results declared earlier this week.

Continue Reading

India News

Rahul Gandhi and Vijay alliance took shape through backchannel talks, early signals from Congress leaders

Congress outreach and political calculations led to Rahul Gandhi and Vijay coming together after the Tamil Nadu 2026 election results.

Published

on

The coming together of Rahul Gandhi and actor-politician Vijay in Tamil Nadu after the 2026 Assembly elections was not sudden, but the result of behind-the-scenes political manoeuvring and early signals within the Congress.

According to media reports, some leaders in the Tamil Nadu Congress had already sensed the scale of Vijay’s surge during the campaign, anticipating what was later described as a “wave” in favour of his party.

After the results, where Vijay’s Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam (TVK) emerged as the single largest party but fell short of a majority, communication channels between the Congress leadership and Vijay quickly became active.

A key moment in this evolving political equation was a phone call from Rahul Gandhi to Vijay, congratulating him on the party’s strong performance. The conversation was seen as more than a courtesy, signalling the possibility of cooperation at a time when government formation required additional support.

Reports indicate that discussions within Congress weighed the political benefits of supporting Vijay, especially given the shifting dynamics in the state where traditional dominance by major Dravidian parties has been challenged.

With TVK needing allies to cross the majority mark, Congress emerged as a potential partner, leading to a broader political realignment in the state. This development also triggered tensions within opposition alliances, highlighting the strategic importance of the decision.

The evolving partnership reflects a mix of electoral pragmatism and changing voter sentiment, particularly the growing influence of younger voters, which leaders acknowledged as a key factor in the election outcome.

Continue Reading

Trending

© Copyright 2022 APNLIVE.com