Fact-Check: Showtime 2020 docu footage passed off as new Taliban video
Everything related to the Taliban, Afghanistan and the women of Afghanistan is viral material. A particular video has been doing the rounds of unidentified Taliban militiamen laughing at a woman interviewer in burqa, asking them if they would respect a woman politician
Everything related to the Taliban, Afghanistan and the women of Afghanistan is viral material. A particular video has been doing the rounds of unidentified Taliban militiamen laughing at a woman interviewer in burqa, asking them if they would respect a woman politician if she is voted into power in elections.
As the whole world has seen and continues to churn out text to mock the Taliban or fury-tweet against the “medieval forces”, the man asks the camera to be turned off since he wants to laugh.
This clip has surfaced after the Taliban’s taking of Kabul on August 15. It follows a meme of CNN journalist Clarissa Ward with her head uncovered and in a burqa, to make the point that Ward had to suddenly find a burqa to continue doing her work. Ward has herself corrected the meme, saying even before the Taliban overran Kabul, she would cover her head with a scarf in deference to local Muslim custom.
The laughing Taliban video, however, plays the usual trope trick of the nasty other who cannot fathom women’s lib. Those who saw the video didn’t even look closely to see a huge Showtime logo at its bottom right. Popular Showtime TV shows include Penny Dreadful, Dexter etc. Further, camera angles in the video also point to the fact that this part of a documentary and not news TV. But viral boss, viral.
Instead of fact-check sites, let us tell you that a Google search would show that Showtime had indeed produced a documentary on Afghanistan released in 2020. Long before the United States decided to up and scram. The US did, however, engage with the largest force in the country, the Taliban, unelected they may be but are the all-pervading power which opposed the American occupation of Afghanistan.
It isn’t that the Americans didn’t know the Talibs would implement Sharia law on their return. Or would wonder how long the house of cards with Ashraf Ghani on top would survive with the ragtag Taliban powering in on Humvees and Toyota trucks.
The Taliban’s lightning progress in the last few weeks has not been examined. There has been some unexplained, mysterious caving in of the Afghan National Army, like personnel changing out of their uniforms and getting into tribal wear.
But WhatsApp university forwards are part and parcel of smartphone lives and we will continue to see this video forwarded to us many more times by the near and dear. There are worse people who share old videos of the Islamic State and its summary executions of women in Syria to decry the Taliban.
Also the Taliban have become convenient tools to revive religious polarization ahead of state elections next year.
Social media giant Meta will soon be summoned by India’s Parliamentary Standing Committee on Communication and Information Technology over CEO Mark Zuckerberg’s comments regarding the 2024 Indian general election. Nishikant Dubey, BJP MP and chairman of the panel, stated that Meta would be held accountable for allegedly spreading misinformation.
“Misinformation in a democratic country damages its image. The organization must apologize to the Parliament and the people for this mistake,” Dubey said in a post on X.
Zuckerberg, during a January 10 podcast, referred to the global erosion of trust in governments post-Covid. He claimed that in 2024, major elections worldwide, including India’s, saw incumbents losing power, linking this trend to factors such as inflation, economic policies, and pandemic handling.
The statement was swiftly fact-checked by Union Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw, who clarified that India’s 2024 general elections reaffirmed public trust in the NDA led by Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
“As the world’s largest democracy, India conducted its 2024 elections with over 640 million voters. People reaffirmed their trust in the NDA under PM Modi’s leadership. Zuckerberg’s claim is factually incorrect,” Vaishnaw posted on X.
He also highlighted Modi’s governance during Covid, emphasizing free food for 800 million citizens, 2.2 billion free vaccines, and economic recovery efforts that positioned India as a fast-growing economy. Vaishnaw expressed disappointment in Meta for allowing such misinformation, urging the platform to prioritize factual reporting.
While the BJP saw a slight dip in seats during the 2024 elections, the NDA comfortably retained power with its allies’ support. This marked Modi’s historic third consecutive term as Prime Minister, making him only the second Indian leader after Jawaharlal Nehru to achieve this milestone.
The controversy surrounding Zuckerberg’s remarks underscores the growing scrutiny of social media platforms in influencing political discourse and the need for accountability in the digital space.
Two soldiers were tragically killed and two others injured when an Army vehicle skidded off the road and plunged into a gorge in Jammu and Kashmir’s Bandipora district on Saturday.
The accident took place near the SK Payen area, leaving the soldiers with serious injuries. The injured personnel were promptly rushed to a nearby hospital for treatment, while the loss of the two soldiers has left the entire region in mourning.
This unfortunate incident follows another similar tragedy that occurred just a month ago in Poonch. In that accident, five soldiers lost their lives, and five others were injured when their truck fell into a 300-foot gorge. The Army’s White Knight Corps paid tribute to the fallen soldiers, sharing a statement on social media expressing their deepest condolences for the “brave soldiers” who had been serving on operational duty in the Poonch sector.
The latest loss has drawn widespread expressions of grief from political leaders. Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Omar Abdullah expressed his sorrow, while Congress leader Rahul Gandhi offered his heartfelt tributes to the martyrs. He also wished for a swift recovery for the injured soldiers and extended his deepest condolences to their grieving families.
These two incidents highlight the ongoing risks faced by soldiers in the line of duty, and the sacrifices made in protecting the nation. Authorities are continuing their investigation into the cause of the accident, while the military community comes together to mourn the tragic losses.
A 30-year-old Indian man, Badal Babu, from Uttar Pradesh’s Aligarh district, is in judicial custody in Pakistan after illegally crossing the border to meet his Facebook friend, only to be rejected. The woman, identified as 21-year-old Sana Rani, told authorities she has no interest in marrying him.
The arrest took place in Mandi Bahauddin, a district in Pakistan’s Punjab province, roughly 240 kilometers from Lahore. Babu was detained under sections 13 and 14 of Pakistan’s Foreign Act for entering the country without proper documentation.
A Facebook friendship turns sour
According to Punjab police officer Nasir Shah, the duo had been friends on Facebook for over two and a half years. Babu, in love with Rani, decided to cross the border illegally to propose. However, Rani’s statement to the police made it clear she had no intention of marrying him.
Shah added, “Babu crossed into Pakistan illegally and reached Maung village, where he was apprehended. Whether he met Rani in person remains unclear.”
Family under scrutiny
Reports suggest that intelligence officials questioned Rani and her family about her relationship with Babu. Although there is speculation that Rani may have given her statement under duress, this remains unconfirmed.
Legal proceedings begin
Babu, who narrated his “love story” to authorities, was presented in court, which placed him in judicial custody for 14 days. His next hearing is scheduled for January 10.
A familiar tale across borders
Babu’s story echoes previous cross-border romances fostered through social media or online games.
In a widely publicized case, Indian woman Anju traveled to Pakistan to marry Nasrullah, converting to Islam before tying the knot.
Similarly, Seema Haider, a Pakistani woman, crossed into India via Nepal to marry her PUBG friend after bringing her four children along.
Last year, 19-year-old Pakistani girl Iqra Jiwani married Indian national Mulayam Singh Yadav in Nepal after meeting him online.
While these cases highlight the unifying power of social media, they also underscore the legal and personal challenges of navigating cross-border relationships.
APN News is today the most watched and the most credible and respected news channel in India. APN has been at the forefront of every single news revolution. The channel is being recognized for its in-depth, analytical reportage and hard hitting discussions on burning issues; without any bias or vested interests.