Veteran actor Anupam Kher and filmmaker Hansal Mehta engaged in a heated exchange regarding their film The Accidental Prime Minister after Mehta concurred with a journalist’s assertion that the 2019 political drama contained “lies” about former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh.
Singh, credited as a key architect of India’s economic reforms, passed away at the age of 92 at Delhi’s All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS). He served as Prime Minister from 2004 to 2014.
The controversy ignited with a post from senior journalist Vir Sanghvi, who referred to The Accidental Prime Minister, based on the memoir of Singh’s former media advisor Sanjay Baru, as “one of the worst Hindi movies ever made.”
The film featured Kher portraying Singh and Akshaye Khanna as Baru, directed by Vijay Gutte, and illustrated the political landscape during Singh’s administration, highlighting his challenges and the Congress party’s influence.
Sanghvi’s tweet stated, “If you want to remember the lies that were told about Manmohan Singh you should rewatch The Accidental Prime Minister. It is not only one of the worst Hindi movies ever made but is an example of how media was used to tarnish the name of a good man.”
Mehta, 56, reacted by sharing Sanghvi’s post and adding, “+100.” Earlier, he had expressed condolences over Singh’s death and stated that the nation “owes him an apology,” affirming, “More than anybody else, I owe him one.”
Kher was incensed by Mehta’s agreement with Sanghvi and labeled him a “hypocrite,” emphasizing that Mehta had served as the film’s creative director, thus having taken part in its production process.
“The HYPOCRITE in this thread is NOT @virsanghvi. He has the freedom to not like a film. But @mehtahansal was the #CreativeDirector of #TheAccidentalPrimeMinister,” Kher remarked, noting Mehta’s presence during the film’s shoot and the assumption that he had received compensation for his work.
While Kher acknowledged that he disagreed with Sanghvi’s perspective, he argued that artists should take ownership of their work, regardless of its quality. He also recalled old posts from Mehta that congratulated him, Khanna, and Gutte for their contributions to the film, which he shared without additional comments.
In response, Mehta confirmed his accountability for the film, stating, “And I can admit that I made a mistake. Can’t I sir? I did my job as professionally as I was allowed to. Can you deny that? But it doesn’t mean I have to keep defending the film or that it makes me lose objectivity about my error of judgment.” Additionally, he expressed regret for unintentionally hurting Kher and offered to discuss any misunderstandings when the time was right.