English हिन्दी
Connect with us

India News

In new guidelines against mob violence, self-appointed guardian of law to compensate victim: SC

Published

on

In new guidelines against mob violence, self-appointed guardian of law to compensate victim: SC

Coming down hard on mob violence, the Supreme Court on Monday, October 1, issued an extensive set of guidelines to check mob violence and prevent hooligans from indulging in vandalism.

In an order that hits at the misplaced pride and sense of impunity among perpetrators of mob violence, the top court said those who indulge in such acts resulting in loss of life or damage to public or private property either directly or indirectly, shall be made liable to compensate the victims of such violence.

The guidelines were part of the last order of Justice Dipak Misra hours before he demitted office as the 45th Chief Justice of India on Monday (October 1).
Dipak Misra
The new set of guidelines are in addition to the directions given by the bench of Chief Justice (now retired) Dipak Misra and Justices AM Khanwilkar and DY Chandrachud earlier this year in the Tehseen Poonawalla case. The Court had laid down strident instructions to rein in vigilante groups, particularly those who had been wreaking havoc across the country over the past four years in the name of protecting the cow.

“Nobody has the right to become a self-appointed guardian of the law and forcibly administer his or her own interpretation of the law on others, especially not with violent means,” the bench said.

The bench further said, “Mob violence runs against the very core of our established legal principles since it signals chaos and lawlessness and the State has a duty to protect its citizens against the illegal and reprehensible acts of such groups.”

It also noted the submissions of Attorney General K K Venugopal who had unequivocally said that violent protests leading to loss of life and damage to public and private properties were against the spirit of democracy and had told the court that an amendment in the law was in the offing to deal with such offences.

The Supreme Court made it clear that states have a duty to protect the citizens.

Deprecating the “disconcerting rise” in violent protests and demonstrations by private entities targeting exhibition of movies, social functions and sections of people on moral grounds, the court said that such acts highlighted deeper malaise of “intolerance” towards views of others and passed a slew of directions to curb such incidents.

“In addition to being patently illegal and unlawful, such acts of violence highlight a deeper malaise, one of intolerance towards others’ views which then results in attempts to suppress alternate view points, artistic integrity and the freedom of speech and expression guaranteed by the Constitution of India,” the bench said.

It added: “Indeed, the people who perpetrate such actions, especially against private parties, do so without fear of consequence and reprisal, probably believing that private parties do not have the wherewithal to hold them accountable for such actions.”

The bench referred to its directions passed in cases related to cow vigilantism, mob violence and instances of honour killings and said that all those measures have to be followed by the states to ensure that no such incidents take place.

“The person/persons who has/have initiated, promoted, instigated or any way caused to occur any act of violence against cultural programmes or which results in loss of life or damage to public or private property either directly or indirectly, shall be made liable to compensate the victims of such violence,” the bench said, adding that states would have to also set up helpline numbers in this regard.

The SC Bench said the court was conscious that crimes committed by groups of “self-appointed keepers of public morality” might be on account of different reasons, but the purpose was to exercise unlawful power of authority and create fear in the minds of public.
The verdict has come on a plea filed by Kodungallur Film Society which had highlighted the serious law and order problem that had arisen before the release of controversial movie ‘Padmaavat’.

The bench said that states must step in and perform their duty by taking measures to prevent such acts from occurring in the first place, and ensure that law-enforcement agencies exercise their power to bring the guilty to book and impose time-bound and adequate punishment for any lapses.

It said: “This court has time and time again underscored the supremacy of law and that one must not forget that administration of law can only be done by law-enforcing agencies recognised by law.

It said: “A comprehensive structure will have to be evolved in the respective states so that the issues of accountability and efficiency in curbing incidents of peaceful protests turning into mob violence, causing damage to property including investigation, remedial and punitive measures, are duly addressed”.

The verdict also took note of its 2009 judgement in which various directions were passed after taking cognisance of various incidents of large scale destruction of public and private properties in the name of “agitations, bandhs and hartals”.

It said that additional responsibilities would be fastened upon the nodal officers who have been appointed in pursuance of the earlier verdict in the mob violence case.

Now, these nodal officers would also be responsible for creating and maintaining a list of cultural establishments, including theatres, cinema halls, music venues, performance halls and centres and art galleries within the district, and pin point such vulnerable establishments which have been attacked/damaged by mob over the past five years.

It said that these measures have to implemented by the Centre and states governments expeditiously within a period of eight weeks.

The bench also said that when any act of violence results in damage to property, the concerned police officials should file FIRs and complete the investigation as far as possible within the statutory period and submit a report in that regard.

The new set of directives, the bench said, will have to be implemented by the Centre and the State Governments in addition to the guidelines laid out in the mob lynching (Tehseen Poonawalla) case and in Re: Destruction of Public and Private Properties v. Govt of AP (2009).

“The recommendations that we have made be implemented by the Central and State governments as expeditiously as possible, preferably within a period of 8 (eight) weeks from today,” Justice Khanwilkar said in the verdict.

The bench has issued five sets of directions, which are as follows:
A. Structural and preventive measures
a) In addition to the responsibilities ascribed to the Nodal Officer(s) as set out in Tehseen Poonawalla (supra), the said Nodal Officer(s) would also be responsible for creating and maintaining a list containing the various cultural establishments, including theatres, cinema halls, music venues, performance halls and centres and art galleries within the district, and pin point vulnerable cultural establishments and property which have been attacked/damaged by mob violence over the past 5 (five) years. This list would be updated on a regular basis to account for any new openings/closings of establishments.

b) In addition to the prohibition against weaponry laid down in paragraph 12 (II) of In Re: Destruction of Public and Private Properties (supra), any person found to be carrying prohibited weaponry, licensed or otherwise, during protests/demonstrations would prima facie be presumed to have an intention to commit violence and be proceeded in that regard as per law.

c) The State governments should set up Rapid Response Teams preferably district-wise which are specially trained to deal with and can be quickly mobilized to respond to acts of mob violence.

d) The State governments should set up special helplines to deal with instances of mob violence.

e) The State police shall create and maintain a cyber information portal on its website and on its internet-based application(s) for reporting instances of mob violence and destruction of public and private properties.

B. Remedies to minimize, if not extirpate, the impending mob violence
a) The Nodal Officer(s) will coordinate with local emergency services, including police stations, fire brigades, hospital and medical services and disaster management authorities during incidents of mob violence in order to have a comprehensive and consolidated response to the situation.

b) The authorities must consider the use of non-lethal crowd-control devices, like water cannons and tear gas, which cause minimum injury to people but at the same time, act as an effective deterrent against mob force.

c) The authorities must ensure that arrests of miscreants found on the spot are done in the right earnest.

d) The Nodal Officer(s), may consider taking appropriate steps as per law including to impose reasonable restrictions on the social media and internet-based communication services or mobile applications… if the situation so warrants.

e) The Nodal Officer(s) must take coordinated efforts and issue messages across various audio-visual mediums to restore peace and to stop/control rumours.

C. Liability of person causing violence
a) If a call to violence results in damage to property, either directly or indirectly, and has been made through a spokesperson or through social media accounts of any group/organization(s) or by any individual, appropriate action should be taken against such person(s) including under Sections 153A, 295A read with 298 and 425 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.

b) In instances where a group/organisation has staged a protest or demonstration resulting in violence and damage to property, the leaders and office bearers of such group/organisation should physically present themselves for questioning, on their own, within 24 (twenty four) hours, in the police station within whose jurisdiction the violence and damage occurred. Any such person(s) failing to present himself/herself in such manner without any sufficient reason should be proceeded against as a suspect and legal process must be initiated forthwith against him/her including for being declared an absconder in accordance with law.

c) A person arrested for either committing or initiating, promoting, instigating or in any way causing to occur any act of violence which results in loss of life or damage to property may be granted conditional bail upon depositing the quantified loss caused due to such violence or furnishing security for such quantified loss… If the loss is yet to be quantified by the appropriate authority, the judge hearing the bail application may quantify the amount of tentative damages (which shall be subject to final determination thereof by the appropriate authority)…

D. Responsibility of police officials
a) When any act of violence results in damage to property, concerned police officials should file FIRs and complete investigation as far as possible within the statutory period and submit a report in that regard. Any failure to file FIRs and conduct investigations within the statutory period without sufficient cause should be considered as dereliction of duty on behalf of the concerned officer and can be proceeded against by way of departmental action in right earnest.

b) Since the Nodal Officer(s) holds the overall responsibility in each district to prevent mob violence against cultural establishments and against property, any unexplained and/or unsubstantiated delay in filing FIRs and/or conducting investigations in that regard should also be deemed to be inaction on the part of the said Nodal Officer(s).

c) Officer-in-charge should first call upon from the panel of local video operators maintained by the concerned police station to video-record the events. If the said video operators are unable to record the events for whatever reason or if the officer-in-charge is of the opinion that supplementary information is required, then he/she can also call upon private video operators to record the events and request the media for information on the incident in question, if need be.

d) Status reports of the investigation(s)/trial(s) concerning such offences as set out hereinabove, including the results of such trial(s), shall be uploaded on the official website of the concerned State police on a regular basis.

e) In the event of acquittal of any person(s) accused of committing such offences as set out hereinabove, the Nodal Officer(s) must coordinate with the Public Prosecutor for filing appeal against such acquittal, in the right earnest.

E. Compensation
a) The person/persons who has/have initiated, promoted, instigated or any way caused to occur any act of violence against cultural programmes or which results in loss of life or damage to public or private property either directly or indirectly, shall be made liable to compensate the victims of such violence.

b) Claims arising out of such acts of violence should be dealt with in the manner prescribed in paragraph 15 of In Re: Destruction of Public and Private Properties (supra).

c) This compensation should be with regard to the loss of life or damage done to any public or private properties, both movable and immovable.

India News

India’s first bullet train to start in 2027, Surat-Vapi stretch first

India’s first bullet train service is expected to begin in the last quarter of 2027, with the Surat-Vapi section of the Mumbai-Ahmedabad corridor set to open first.

Published

on

bullet train

India’s first high-speed rail service is set to begin in 2027, with the Surat-Vapi section of the Mumbai-Ahmedabad High-Speed Rail corridor planned to open first, Railway Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw has said. The full corridor will become operational in phases.

The minister said the first service would commence in the last quarter of 2027. The announcement marks an updated timeline for the first operational section of the country’s ambitious bullet train project.

Mumbai-Ahmedabad bullet train project

The Mumbai-Ahmedabad High-Speed Rail corridor spans 508 km. The route will connect Mumbai with Ahmedabad through stations including Thane, Virar, Boisar, Vapi, Bilimora, Surat, Bharuch, Vadodara and Anand.

The corridor is being developed in phases, with the sections opening progressively as construction is completed. The full route is planned to provide high-speed connectivity between Mumbai and Ahmedabad.

Construction work progresses

According to Vaishnaw, 456 km of pier work and 371 km of viaduct construction had been completed as of September 2026. Six lakh noise barriers had also been installed along 299 km of the route, while 9,300 overhead electrification masts had been installed across a 206-km viaduct stretch.

Civil work has been completed at eight stations, while architectural finishing is underway. Work is also progressing at the three rolling-stock depots at Sabarmati, Surat and Thane.

India’s first undersea rail tunnel

The project also includes an undersea section beneath Thane Creek. The Maharashtra portion has a 21-km tunnel, of which about 7 km will pass beneath the sea.

Two tunnel boring machines were launched in July 2026 for the tunnelling work.

Indigenous bullet train manufacturing

India is also developing its own high-speed trainsets for the corridor. Integral Coach Factory and BEML are manufacturing the B28 trainset, which is designed for a speed of 280 kmph.

The first train body frame has been completed and is undergoing structural testing, while track trials are expected by mid-2027, according to the minister.

The broader high-speed rail corridor is designed for trains capable of speeds of up to around 320 kmph.

Why the project was delayed

Vaishnaw said the project faced delays because state permissions and land acquisition in Maharashtra remained pending for around two and a half years. The COVID-19 pandemic caused a further delay of about two years, with full construction beginning in earnest in 2021, according to his account.

The project was originally announced in 2017 and is being developed by the National High Speed Rail Corporation Limited with Japanese technology and assistance.

Continue Reading

India News

PM Modi to visit Bengal, Bihar and UP, unveil projects worth Rs. 34,470 Crore

Prime Minister Narendra Modi will visit West Bengal, Bihar and Uttar Pradesh on November 21, including IIT Kharagpur’s platinum jubilee, development projects worth Rs. 34,470 crore in Vaishali and the Kaushal Deekshant Samaroh in Lucknow.

Published

on

PM Modi

Prime Minister Narendra Modi is scheduled to visit West Bengal, Bihar and Uttar Pradesh on Saturday, November 21, with his itinerary including an event at IIT Kharagpur, the inauguration and foundation stone-laying of development projects in Bihar and a national skill development ceremony in Lucknow.

His Bihar programme in Vaishali will include projects worth around Rs. 34,470 crore across sectors, including road connectivity, energy, urban infrastructure, water resources, education, healthcare and transport.

PM Modi’s IIT Kharagpur programme

The prime minister will begin his visit in West Bengal, where he will participate in the platinum jubilee celebrations of IIT Kharagpur.

According to the report, Modi will also interact with 75 students of the institute, representing its 75-year journey. IIT Kharagpur was established in 1951 and was the first Indian Institute of Technology to be established in the country.

Rs. 34,470 crore projects in Bihar

Modi will then travel to Bihar’s Vaishali district, where he will inaugurate development projects and lay foundation stones for new works estimated at around Rs. 34,470 crore.

A key part of the programme is the dedication of Nitish Setu to the nation. The bridge is an extradosed cable-stayed bridge over the Ganga and has been built at a reported cost of around Rs. 4,280 crore, according to the report.

The 19.7-km project connects Kachhi Dargah on NH-22 in Patna district with Bidupur on NH-322 in Vaishali district. It includes a 9.7-km main bridge and 10 km of approach roads.

The wider package of Bihar projects covers road connectivity, energy, urban infrastructure, water resources, education, healthcare and transport.

PM Modi to attend skill development ceremony in Lucknow

The prime minister will conclude his three-state programme in Uttar Pradesh, where he will attend the 5th Kaushal Deekshant Samaroh at Indira Gandhi Pratishthan in Gomti Nagar, Lucknow.

The annual ceremony recognises achievements in the skill development ecosystem and marks the transition of trained youth from skill programmes to the workforce.

This year, 52 national-level toppers from Industrial Training Institutes, National Skill Training Institutes and Institutes for Training of Trainers will be felicitated, according to the report.

The Kaushal Deekshant Samaroh was instituted in the academic session 2021-22 and has since become an annual platform for recognising excellence in vocational and skill development.

Continue Reading

India News

Kiren Rijiju’s 4 questions to Congress over Rahul Gandhi’s compromised PM post

Kiren Rijiju hit back at Rahul Gandhi’s “compromised PM” remark by asking Congress four questions on the 1962 war, poverty, India’s global image and economic growth.

Published

on

Union Minister Kiren Rijiju on Saturday stepped up the BJP’s attack on Congress over Rahul Gandhi’s “compromised PM” remark against Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

In a post on X, Rijiju asked Congress to answer four questions, touching on the 1962 war with China, India’s economic condition, the country’s global image and the phrase “Hindu rate of growth”.

Rijiju’s remarks came after Rahul Gandhi criticised PM Modi over a trilateral meeting involving US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in China.

Gandhi said that if Congress were in power, the Indian Prime Minister would be sitting at the table with the three leaders. He added that a “compromised PM” could not sit there.

What Kiren Rijiju asked Congress

Rijiju listed four questions in his post.

He asked whether Congress would apologise for the “1962 humiliation”, saying that his village was occupied by China during the conflict.

He then questioned why Congress “kept India a poor nation” and asked why India was described as the “land of snake charmers”.

His fourth question concerned the phrase “Hindu rate of growth”, asking why India’s economy was described using the term. These were questions and political criticisms raised by Rijiju against Congress.

Rijiju attacks Rahul Gandhi over India remarks

Rijiju had also criticised Rahul Gandhi while speaking to reporters on Friday, saying the Congress leader should not make statements against India, whether in the country or abroad.

He alleged that Gandhi was working with foreign-based anti-India forces and spreading what he described as falsehoods about India’s democracy and economy. These were Rijiju’s allegations and should not be presented as independently established facts.

The exchange followed Gandhi’s criticism of India’s position in global geopolitics. BJP leaders subsequently attacked the Congress leader over his remarks, with BJP spokesperson Pradeep Bhandari accusing him of being a “Pakistan fanboy”.

The political confrontation comes amid a wider BJP-Congress clash over India’s foreign policy and the country’s role in global affairs.

Continue Reading

Trending

© Copyright 2022 APNLIVE.com