English हिन्दी
Connect with us

India News

Those who took decision on transfer must answer how it was done: Karnataka HC judge Patel after resignation

Published

on

Karnataka High Court

[vc_row][vc_column][vc_column_text]Justice Jayant Patel had resigned after learning that he was being transferred to Allahabad HC where he would have been third in queue for chief justice post

Justice Jayant Patel of the Karnataka High Court, who famously ordered a CBI enquiry into the Ishrat Jahan fake encounter case while he was a judge in the Gujarat high court, had sent in his resignation letter to Karnataka’s Chief Justice SK Mukherjee, on Monday. Justice Patel’s decision to quit – 10 months before he was set to retire –had come after he learned that he was being transferred to the Allahabad High Court, a move that would have ensured that he isn’t promoted to the rank of Chief Justice in Karnataka – or Allahabad for that matter.

While his resignation has created a flutter in the legal community of Karnataka, sent ripples across India’s judiciary and reignited the debate on the lack of transparency in the manner in which judges are appointed, transferred or elevated, all that Justice Patel has to say on the chain of events he has triggered is that those who took the decision on his transfer “must answer” on how this was done.

Had Justice Patel not been transferred to the Allahabad High Court he would have, by convention, been elevated to the rank of Chief Justice of the Karnataka High Court. Incumbent Karnataka Chief Justice Mukherjee is set to retire on October 9, and Justice Patel was the next senior-most judge in the court. However, had he moved to the Allahabad High Court, Justice Patel would have been the third seniormost and with just 10 months left for his retirement, he would have effectively been out of the race for a promotion.

In an interview to the Indian Express, Justice Patel declined to attribute motives to the Supreme Court collegiums for deciding to transfer him to the Allahabad High Court and robbing him of his elevation but said: “Those who have taken decisions must answer how it was done. I cannot say anything”.

The judge, who enjoys support and respect across bar associations of Gujarat – where he had briefly been elevated as Acting Chief Justice before being transferred to the southern state as a regular judge – and Karnataka refused to link the denial of his confirmation as Chief Justice to his landmark decision of ordering a CBI probe in the Ishrat Jahan encounter case in 2011.

“When I became aware about my contemplated transfer to the Allahabad High Court, I decided to resign. I have already sent my resignation to the President of India. From yesterday, I am relieved of responsibilities. How it happened and what happened is for you to consider,” the Indian Express quoted Justice Patel as saying.

“I had no desire to be shifted to Allahabad. I have worked with dignity for 16 years as a judge, and for (the remaining) ten months why should I go to another place,” Justice Patel added.

Clearly anguished over being forced to resign and being denied what many feel was his rightful due, Justice Patel said: “What I feel is that I did my duty as per the oath of my office. Punishment is ultimately in God’s hands. One thing I can say is that wherever I worked, it has been with all sincerity and strictly as per my oath of office.”

Asked specifically if he would have been elevated had he not ordered the CBI probe in the Ishrat Jahan encounter – a case that had pointed fingers at the then Gujarat chief minister and now Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the then minister of state for home in Gujarat, Amit Shah, who is now the BJP national president – Justice Patel said: “Everyday we take decisions. We do not look at whether the case is about X or Y and we cannot decide a matter like that. We do not see the name of the party and decide the course. This is what is expected of us. I don’t think this could be the reason (for my transfer) but I cannot answer as the decisions were taken by someone else.’’

Senior Supreme Court advocates Dushyant Dave and Yatin Oza have both indicated that Justice Patel was denied the Chief Justice’s rank on account of his decision to order a CBI probe into the Ishrat Jahan case.

Advocates who met him after news of his resignation broke on Tuesday in an effort to get him to reconsider his decision said that Jutice Patel had conveyed that matters were beyond reconsideration.[/vc_column_text][/vc_column][/vc_row]

India News

Passengers must pay charges for excess luggage on trains, says railway minister

Passengers travelling by train will need to pay extra charges if their luggage exceeds the prescribed free allowance, the railway minister informed Parliament.

Published

on

Ashwini Vaishnaw

Indian Railways passengers will have to pay additional charges if they carry luggage beyond the prescribed free allowance during train journeys. The clarification was given by Railway Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw in the Lok Sabha, outlining existing class-wise baggage norms and the charges applicable for excess weight.

The minister explained that Indian Railways already follows a structured luggage policy, under which passengers are allowed a fixed free allowance depending on their travel class, with a defined maximum limit that cannot be exceeded inside passenger compartments.

Class-wise luggage limits explained

According to the details shared in Parliament, passengers travelling in Second Class are permitted to carry up to 35 kg of luggage free of cost. They can carry additional luggage up to 70 kg, but only after paying the prescribed charges.

For Sleeper Class travellers, the free allowance stands at 40 kg, with the maximum permissible limit capped at 80 kg, including the free allowance. Passengers in AC 3 Tier and AC Chair Car are allowed to carry 40 kg of luggage, which is also the upper limit for these classes.

First Class and AC 2 Tier passengers can carry up to 50 kg of luggage free of cost, with a maximum limit of 100 kg. AC First Class passengers have the highest allowance, with 70 kg permitted free and up to 150 kg allowed on a chargeable basis.

The railway minister clarified that the maximum limit in each class includes the free allowance and that passengers cannot exceed this limit inside the compartments.

Charges for excess luggage and size restrictions

Vaishnaw stated that passengers carrying luggage beyond the free allowance, but within the maximum limit, are required to pay charges at 1.5 times the standard luggage rate. Such excess luggage can be carried along with the passenger inside the compartment after payment.

The Railways also impose size restrictions on personal luggage. Trunks, suitcases and boxes with outer dimensions up to 100 cm × 60 cm × 25 cm are allowed in passenger compartments. Items exceeding any one of these dimensions must be booked separately and carried in brake vans or parcel vans, not inside passenger coaches.

The minister further clarified that merchandise items are not permitted to be carried as personal luggage in passenger compartments. Any luggage beyond the prescribed limits is required to be booked and transported in the brake van of the train, subject to existing booking norms.

Continue Reading

India News

Lok Sabha passes SHANTI Bill, opens civil nuclear sector to private participation

The Lok Sabha has passed the SHANTI Bill, paving the way for private participation in India’s civil nuclear sector and supporting the target of 100 GW atomic energy by 2047.

Published

on

Lok Sabha

The Lok Sabha on Wednesday passed the Sustainable Harnessing and Advancement of Nuclear Energy for Transforming India (SHANTI) Bill, a move that allows private players to enter India’s tightly regulated civil nuclear sector. The legislation was approved through a voice vote, even as opposition members staged a walkout during the discussion.

Union minister Jitendra Singh described the passage of the bill as a milestone, saying it would help the country move closer to its long-term clean energy goals. According to the minister, the legislation is aligned with India’s ambition to generate 100 gigawatts of atomic energy capacity by 2047.

Focus on clean energy and long-term targets

Speaking in the House, Singh said India’s growing role on the global stage requires it to follow international benchmarks, particularly in the transition towards cleaner energy sources. He noted that nuclear power would play a crucial role in meeting future energy demands while reducing dependence on conventional fuels.

The SHANTI Bill aims to bring private participation into the civil nuclear space, which has so far remained largely under government control. The government has maintained that such participation is necessary to scale up capacity and meet the 2047 nuclear energy target.

Opposition flags liability concerns

Opposition parties opposed the bill, arguing that it weakens provisions of the Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Act, 2010. They claimed that the proposed framework shifts responsibility in the event of a nuclear incident away from suppliers of nuclear equipment, raising concerns over accountability.

Despite these objections, the bill was passed, marking a significant policy shift in India’s nuclear energy sector.

Continue Reading

India News

Bharat Taxi to launch in Delhi on January 1 as cooperative alternative to app-based cabs

Bharat Taxi, a government-backed cooperative cab service, will be launched in Delhi on January 1 as an alternative to app-based taxi platforms.

Published

on

bharat taxi model

Delhi residents will soon have a new option for daily commuting as Bharat Taxi, India’s first cooperative taxi service, is set to begin operations in the national capital from January 1. The service has been launched by the Centre as an alternative to existing app-based cab platforms and is expected to operate alongside them.

According to information shared by government sources, all preparations for the launch in Delhi have been completed. The service will function through a mobile application operated by Sahakar Taxi Cooperative Limited and will follow a zero-commission model.

Multiple ride options and app-based features

Bharat Taxi will offer cars, auto-rickshaws and bikes through its platform. The app will be available on both Android and iOS devices. Users will be able to register using their mobile number, select pick-up and drop-off locations, choose a vehicle, and track their ride in real time.

The application includes features such as a transparent fare structure, real-time vehicle tracking, multilingual interface, and 24×7 customer support. Safety measures include verified driver onboarding, integration with Delhi Police and other agencies, and an option to share ride details with others.

Focus on fair pricing and ride reliability

The cooperative taxi service aims to address issues commonly faced by commuters, including surge pricing during peak hours, ride cancellations, and drivers refusing trips. Provisions have been made within the system to deal with such everyday complaints.

Officials indicated that the platform is designed to bring predictability to fares while ensuring a smoother experience for passengers.

Driver-owned model to improve earnings

A key feature of Bharat Taxi is its driver-owned cooperative structure. Under this model, drivers are expected to receive up to 80 per cent of the fare directly, supported by a monthly credit system. The initiative is intended to provide drivers with higher income and improved working conditions, reducing dependence on private cab aggregators.

Government sources said the platform offers drivers a more independent and equitable alternative for earning a livelihood.

Expansion plans beyond Delhi

As per official information, around 56,000 drivers have already registered on the Bharat Taxi app. While testing has been completed in Delhi, a similar trial is currently underway in Rajkot, Gujarat, where the service is expected to be launched on February 1.

Officials added that Bharat Taxi will be gradually expanded to more than 20 cities across the country in the coming phase.

Continue Reading

Trending

© Copyright 2022 APNLIVE.com